2025 All-Star Ballot Guide: Key Players In, Out, and On the Bubble

The MLB All-Star Game isn’t just an exhibition. It’s a wild celebration of baseball’s biggest names—a blend of stats, fan favorites, and jaw-dropping moments.

Will Leitch’s 2025 MLB All-Star Ballot guide tries to nail the perfect ballot. He juggles current stats, a bit of history, and that elusive entertainment factor.

From first base to designated hitters, Leitch goes for players who light up the field and win over fans. Here’s a look at his picks and what’s behind each one.

The Challenge of All-Star Voting

All-Star voting is a weird mix of numbers and gut feeling. MLB’s two-phase fan vote lets people weigh stats, popularity, or both—whatever feels right in the moment.

Leitch works through these factors to create a ballot that’s both logical and honestly, a little emotional. Let’s get into his choices, starting with the infield and moving out.

First Base: A Tale of Star Power and Consistency

First base always brings the star power. In the AL, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. gets Leitch’s vote—not just for his numbers, but for that magnetic energy he brings to the game.

In the NL, Freddie Freeman stands out. His .349 batting average just can’t be ignored.

Second Base: Legacy Meets Emerging Talent

Second base was a tougher call, but both leagues have strong contenders. In the AL, José Altuve’s steady play and reputation make him an easy pick.

Over in the NL, Ketel Marte’s breakout season puts him right at the top. These two show how current hot streaks and long-term excellence can both matter.

Hot Corners and Electric Shortstops

Third base and shortstop demand athleticism and versatility. This year’s crop is loaded.

Third Base: Dominance on Both Sides of the Diamond

The AL’s José Ramírez secures his spot with steady hitting and all-around play. In the NL, Manny Machado’s reliable excellence makes him hard to pass up.

Durability and proven performance play a big role in these picks.

Shortstop: A Crowded Field of Stars

Shortstop is stacked this year. Leitch lands on Bobby Witt Jr. for the AL—his all-around game and electric presence make him a clear favorite.

For the NL, Francisco Lindor’s bounce-back season puts him back in the spotlight. He’s earned his place on the ballot.

Behind the Plate and in the Outfield

Catchers and outfielders have to do it all—defense, offense, and sometimes a little showmanship. Leitch looks for players who bring the full package.

Catchers: Power Meets Precision

Cal Raleigh gets the nod in the AL. He brings home-run power and comes through in big moments.

In the NL, Will Smith’s season behind the plate is just too good to ignore. He’s become one of the most dependable catchers around.

Outfield: A Showcase of Superstar Talent

The outfield is always stacked, and 2025 might be one of the best years yet. For the AL, Leitch goes with Aaron Judge, Julio Rodríguez, and George Springer—a powerhouse trio with a mix of youth and experience.

The NL group features Corbin Carroll, Juan Soto, and Pete Crow-Armstrong. These guys bring skill and a little bit of drama to every game.

Designated Hitters: The Heavy Hitters

No All-Star Game is complete without the best designated hitters. Rafael Devers takes the AL spot for his bat, while Shohei Ohtani is the obvious pick for the NL.

Ohtani’s ability to dominate as both a hitter and pitcher? It’s unreal. He’s a must for any All-Star ballot.

Capturing the Spirit of the All-Star Game

Leitch’s 2025 All-Star Ballot guide isn’t just about picking the “best” players. It’s about capturing the essence of what makes baseball special.

By blending statistical excellence with fan appeal and those unforgettable moments, Leitch puts together a lineup that’s more about the joy of the game than just raw talent. Isn’t that what keeps us coming back year after year?

 
Here is the source article for this story: In, out and on the bubble: Leitch’s 2025 All-Star ballot guide