Gerry Staley retired from Major League Baseball in 1961, wrapping up a 15-season career that stretched from 1947 to 1961. The right-handed pitcher from Brush Prairie, Washington, built a solid reputation mainly with the St. Louis Cardinals and Chicago White Sox. He posted a 134-111 record and a 3.70 ERA over 640 games.
Late in his career, Staley made a shift from starting pitcher to one of the American League’s most effective relief specialists. That move really changed the trajectory of his career.
Staley’s biggest moment happened on September 22, 1959. He came into a tense game against Cleveland with the bases loaded and one out in the ninth. With nerves of steel, he got a game-ending double play that clinched the American League pennant for the Chicago White Sox, their first in 40 years.
That clutch outing summed up the kind of steady pitching that made Staley a go-to guy for his teams.
Staley’s career reflects how baseball changed in the 1950s and early 1960s, especially as teams started to value relief pitching more. He started out as a young pitcher with the Cardinals and then, as he got older, became a closer for the White Sox. It’s a great example of how players adapted to stick around in the big leagues.
His personal life, stats, and the mark he left on his teams show a guy who squeezed every bit of talent out of his career during one of baseball’s golden eras.
Who Was Gerry Staley?
Gerald Lee Staley was a professional baseball pitcher who put together a 15-year run in Major League Baseball from 1947 to 1961. Born in rural Washington state, he went from playing sandlot games on the weekends to becoming a reliable major league starter.
Eventually, he reinvented himself as one of the American League’s best relievers.
Early Life and Background
Gerald Lee Staley was born on August 21, 1920, in Brush Prairie, Washington. His parents were lumberman Adelbert Randolph Staley and Clementine Steelman.
He grew up in Clark County, just outside Vancouver, in southern Washington during the 1920s and 1930s.
Staley came from an athletic family. “Both of my older brothers were better ballplayers than I was,” he admitted in a 2003 interview. “But they just never got the break that I got.”
He went to high school in Battle Ground and graduated in 1938. After that, he worked for a couple of years at Alcoa Aluminum in Vancouver and played sandlot baseball on weekends.
At six feet tall with a strong arm, Staley usually played shortstop because he could make those long throws to first base. In his third season, he started pitching too, and that turned out to be his ticket to pro baseball.
Path to the Major Leagues
Staley got his shot at professional baseball thanks to a connection at Alcoa. A coworker who had played in the Pacific Coast League knew Jim Keesey, manager of the Boise Pilots in the Class-C Pioneer League.
“The fella I was working with asked me if I wanted to go and try out, and I did,” Staley said. Since he wasn’t old enough to sign a contract, Keesey talked with his parents, who encouraged him to go for it.
Staley quit his job at the aluminum plant and made the Boise team in 1941. He had a standout debut, going 22-8 with a 2.79 ERA. He led the league in games, innings pitched, and wins.
After a strong 1942 season (20-10, 2.73 ERA), Staley joined the Army’s Medical Corps. He spent most of World War II in the South Pacific.
The St. Louis Cardinals picked up his rights after the war through an agreement with Sacramento of the Coast League.
Major League Career Overview
Gerry Staley pitched in Major League Baseball for 15 seasons, from 1947 to 1961. He racked up a 134-111 record with a 3.70 ERA in 640 games.
He started out as a successful starter with the St. Louis Cardinals. Later, he became a dominant reliever with the Chicago White Sox. He retired after the 1961 season.
MLB Debut and Initial Impact
Staley made his major league debut on April 20, 1947, with the St. Louis Cardinals at age 26. He threw two scoreless innings against the Chicago Cubs, didn’t allow a hit, and struck out one batter.
The Cardinals sent him to Columbus of the American Association on July 23, 1947. In the minors, he went 6-1 before returning to St. Louis later that season.
Staley got his first complete game win in September 1947. He wrapped up his rookie year with a 1-0 record and a 2.76 ERA in 18 games for the Cardinals.
His big break came in 1949 when the Cardinals sold Murry Dickson to the Pirates. “I became a regular in 1949 when they sold Murry Dickson to the Pirates,” Staley recalled. “That deal opened the way for me.”
From 1951 to 1953, Staley proved himself as a steady starter. He won 19 games in 1951, then 17 in 1952, and 18 in 1953. His sinkerball and sharp control got him picked for the All-Star team in 1952 and 1953.
Transition from Starter to Reliever
Staley hit a rough patch in 1954, going 7-13 with a 5.26 ERA. The Cardinals traded him to Cincinnati on December 8, 1954, along with Ray Jablonski for Frank Smith.
After short runs with Cincinnati and the New York Yankees, Staley joined the Chicago White Sox on May 28, 1956. Manager Marty Marion already knew what Staley could do from their days together in St. Louis.
Al Lopez took over as Chicago’s manager in 1957 and moved Staley to the bullpen full-time. The White Sox had solid starters like Billy Pierce, Dick Donovan, and Bob Keegan, so they needed someone steady in relief.
“Lopez came and he figured he needed some people in the bullpen,” Staley explained. “He needed somebody there who wouldn’t take too long to warm up, and who wouldn’t come up with arm trouble.”
Between 1957 and 1960, Staley dominated as a reliever. His 2.43 ERA and 30 relief wins led all American League relievers during that stretch. He played a big part in the White Sox winning the 1959 American League pennant, their first in four decades.
Retirement in 1961
Staley’s last season came in 1961 with the Detroit Tigers. He didn’t see much action as his long career wound down.
He played his final game on September 25, 1961, at age 41. Over 15 years, he pitched for six different teams.
Staley finished with 134 wins, 111 losses, and 727 strikeouts. His 3.70 ERA showed how steady he was, no matter what role or team.
The Washington native made the rare move from starter to reliever at a time when that wasn’t common. His ability to adapt stretched out his career and made him a valuable asset for several teams.
Team Contributions and Notable Seasons
Gerry Staley spent 15 years in the majors, showing he could succeed as both a starter and a reliever for six different teams. He had his best years as a starter with the St. Louis Cardinals from 1947-1954, then reinvented himself as a top reliever with the Chicago White Sox from 1956-1960.
St. Louis Cardinals Years
Staley kicked off his major league career with the St. Louis Cardinals in 1947 after they picked him up from Sacramento. He debuted on April 20, 1947, at age 26.
He broke through in 1949 with a 10-10 record and a 2.73 ERA. That year, he led the Cardinals pitching staff in earned run average.
Staley’s peak came between 1951 and 1953. He won 19 games in 1951, then 17 in 1952, and 18 in 1953. In 1953, he posted a career-best 18-9 record.
His sinkerball, changeup, and the occasional knuckleball made him tough to hit. He earned All-Star selections in 1952 and 1953.
Things went south in 1954 when he went 7-13 with a 5.26 ERA. The Cardinals traded him to Cincinnati on December 8, 1954, along with Ray Jablonski for reliever Frank Smith.
Chicago White Sox Tenure
The Chicago White Sox got Staley from the New York Yankees on May 28, 1956. Manager Marty Marion first used him mostly as a starter.
When Al Lopez took over as manager in 1957, he made Staley a full-time reliever. That move gave Staley’s career new life.
From 1957 to 1960, Staley became one of the best relievers in the American League. He put up a 2.43 ERA over those four years, leading all AL relievers.
He also notched 30 relief wins, the most in the league during that span. Staley racked up 38 saves, just behind Ryne Duren’s 42.
In 1959, he helped the White Sox win their first pennant in 40 years. On September 22, 1959, he came into a bases-loaded jam in Cleveland and got a double play to end the game and clinch the AL pennant.
Stints with Cincinnati Redlegs and New York Yankees
Staley’s time with the Cincinnati Redlegs in 1955 didn’t go well. He finished 5-8, though he felt like he still pitched well.
“Everything they hit was just in a hole,” Staley said about his time in Cincinnati. He blamed bad luck more than bad pitching.
The New York Yankees picked up Staley from Cincinnati on September 11, 1955. He didn’t pitch much and didn’t get any decisions.
The Yankees left him off their World Series roster that fall. His stint in New York lasted less than a season before Chicago claimed him off waivers.
Final Seasons with Kansas City Athletics and Detroit Tigers
Staley’s career wound down with short stops at two American League teams. The Kansas City Athletics picked him up from Chicago as his effectiveness started to fade.
He spent his last season with the Detroit Tigers in 1961. By then, the veteran right-hander was 40 and nearing the end.
He didn’t play much in those final years. Staley’s career totals ended up at 134 wins and 111 losses with a 3.70 ERA over 640 games.
He retired after the 1961 season, closing out a 15-year major league career. His shift from starter to reliever showed real adaptability throughout his time in the game.
Gerry Staley’s Career Statistics
Gerry Staley finished with a 134-111 record and a 3.70 ERA over 15 seasons from 1947 to 1961. He struck out 727 and had solid advanced metrics like FIP and WHIP, showing how effective he was as both a starter and reliever over 640 games.
Win-Loss Record and ERA
Staley wrapped up his career with 134 wins and 111 losses, a .547 winning percentage. His career ERA of 3.70 showed solid performance across different eras.
His best ERA came in 1959 with the Chicago White Sox. That year, he posted a 2.24 ERA in 67 games and helped the White Sox reach the World Series.
Staley’s ERA bounced around a bit over the years. In 1948, he struggled with a 6.92 ERA in 31 games. He turned things around in 1949, posting a 2.73 ERA over 45 appearances.
The move from starter to reliever really helped his numbers. As a closer with Chicago, Staley found his most consistent success. The role change gave him a second wind and let him get the most out of his career.
Strikeouts and Key Metrics
Staley racked up 727 strikeouts over 1,981 innings during his 15-year career. His strikeout rate might seem modest by today’s standards, but honestly, that’s just how pitchers did things back then.
He hit his strikeout peak in 1952, fanning 93 batters in 239.2 innings. That season, he made his first All-Star appearance, showing everyone he belonged as a frontline starter.
Throughout his career, Staley posted a 1.37 K/BB ratio. That number tells you he had pretty good control, even if he didn’t blow hitters away. He faced a whopping 8,398 batters in the majors.
As he moved into relief pitching, his strikeout totals dropped. Still, his knack for getting saves more than made up for the dip in Ks. Later on, he really leaned into quality over quantity.
FIP and WHIP Analysis
Staley’s FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching) numbers give a clearer picture of his real pitching skill. Usually, his FIP sat higher than his ERA, so he probably got a boost from solid defense behind him.
In 1959, his FIP landed at 2.82, right in line with his 2.24 ERA. That kind of match-up shows he truly pitched at an elite level that year. The stats back up that his breakout season was no fluke.
Over his career, his WHIP (Walks plus Hits per Inning Pitched) averaged about 1.30. In 1949, he posted his best WHIP at 1.138, which really highlights his command. As he got older, his WHIP ticked up, a pretty normal sign of aging.
Staley’s advanced stats show why teams valued him as a steady pitcher. Maybe he wasn’t a superstar by today’s numbers, but you could count on him. The numbers add up to a guy who always pulled his weight.
All-Star Appearances and Awards
Staley picked up All-Star selections in 1952 and 1953 with the St. Louis Cardinals. Those nods came during his best years as a starter.
In 1952, he put up a 17-14 record with a 3.27 ERA. He finished 15 complete games that year, which says a lot about his durability. That season really put him on the map as a reliable National League starter.
By 1959, Staley grabbed MVP consideration, finishing 28th in the voting. His 15 saves helped the White Sox snag the American League pennant, right as he was settling into his new role as a closer.
Staley’s 19.1 Wins Above Replacement (WAR) tells you a lot about his career value. He never took home the big awards, but his steady play made him a key piece for every team he joined. The stats paint the picture of a pitcher who squeezed the most out of his talent.
Legacy and Impact on Baseball
Gerry Staley’s career really bridged the old-school world of starting pitchers and the new age of specialized relievers. He played a huge part in helping the Chicago White Sox grab their first pennant in 40 years. Switching from starter to top-tier reliever, he showed just how much the game was changing.
Influence on Pitching Roles
Staley’s career shift changed how teams thought about pitching. For the Cardinals, he posted 19, 17, and 18 wins as a starter between 1951 and 1953. After some rough outings in 1954, he decided to reinvent himself in the bullpen.
When Al Lopez took over as White Sox manager in 1957, he moved Staley full-time to the bullpen. That move turned out to be a game-changer for both Staley and the team. From 1957 to 1960, Staley put up a 2.43 ERA as a reliever, leading all American League relievers in that stretch.
He also led the league with 30 relief wins during those years. Staley set the standard for what we now expect from relief pitchers. He proved that veteran starters could carve out new careers by moving to the pen.
With his sinkerball, Staley got ground balls when it mattered most. He could warm up fast and had the stamina to pitch multiple innings if the team needed it.
Role in 1959 World Series with the White Sox
Staley played a huge role in the Chicago White Sox’s 1959 pennant run. On September 22, 1959, he threw the most important pitch of his career at Cleveland’s Municipal Stadium. The bases were loaded with one out in the ninth, and manager Al Lopez called for Staley.
The White Sox desperately needed a double play to clinch their first pennant in four decades. Staley fired his signature sinker to Vic Power. Power hit a grounder to shortstop Luis Aparicio, who started the double play that ended the game.
That clutch moment sealed the pennant for Chicago. Staley would later say his late-season fatigue actually helped his sinker drop more. The slower pitch had extra movement, making it perfect for ground balls.
The White Sox went on to face the Los Angeles Dodgers in the World Series, but they fell in six games.
Recognition and Remembered Qualities
Staley got recognized as a four-time All-Star during his 15-year run. He made the National League All-Star team in 1952 and 1953 with the Cardinals. His 134-111 record and 3.70 ERA speak to his steady performance in any role.
His sinkerball became legendary among players. The groundskeepers at Sportsman’s Park used to water down the infield dirt when he pitched, making it easier for his sinkers to turn into ground ball outs.
Staley’s control caught the attention of everyone around him. He often finished games with fewer than 100 pitches, sometimes just 80-90, thanks to his knack for quick outs.
His career really showed how important adaptability is in baseball. That move from starter to reliever kept him in the game longer and made the most of his skills as the sport kept changing.
Personal Life and Post-Retirement
Gerald Lee Staley stayed rooted in Clark County, Washington, even with his Army service and all the travel baseball brought. After retiring, he spent 17 years in public service and found joy in simple things like gardening and fishing.
Life After Baseball
Staley made a smooth shift from pro baseball to community service. He worked 17 years as a supervisor for Clark County Parks and Recreation, bringing the leadership he learned on the field to his new job.
Even after all his baseball success, Staley stuck to his Washington roots. He chose to live in the same county where he was born, preferring a simple, stable life instead of chasing the spotlight.
Later on, Staley found peace in the basics. He spent plenty of time gardening and fishing for steelhead, really soaking in everything Washington had to offer.
He also kept in touch with baseball fans all over. He answered fan mail and signed autographs for free. “There are some players who won’t sign unless they get paid for it,” he once said. “What the heck; I’ve got enough to live on. It’s nice to be remembered.”
His post-baseball honors included inductions into the State of Washington Sports Hall of Fame, Clark County Hall of Fame, and Washington State Horseshoe Pitchers Hall of Fame.
Passing and Memorial
Gerald Lee Staley passed away on January 2, 2008, at 87. He died at his Hazel Dell home.
He lost his wife Shirle before his own passing. They spent 55 years together, and honestly, that’s a rare and impressive stretch.
Bill Hersh, a close family friend, shared a memory. “He was a good man, and he lived a good life. He was pretty energetic up to the end.”
Staley leaves behind a son and a daughter. The family decided not to hold a memorial service, and instead, they asked people to send remembrances to his Vancouver address.
His death closed out an era for Clark County baseball. Staley was, in the eyes of many, perhaps the most successful major leaguer to come out of Clark County, and his legacy definitely stretched well beyond just his stats.
Experience Baseball History in Person
Want to walk the same grounds where baseball legends made history? Find accommodations near iconic ballparks across America and create your own baseball pilgrimage.
Check availability at hotels near: Yankee Stadium, Fenway Park, Wrigley Field, Dodger Stadium
Plan your ballpark visit: Get MLB Ballpark Tickets and find accommodations nearby.
- Biographies
- Stadium Guides
- Current Baseball Players
- Current Players by Team
- Players that Retired in the 2020s
- Players that Retired in the 2010s
- Players that Retired in the 2000s
- Players that Retired in the 1990s
- Players that Retired in the 1980s
- Players that Retired in the 1970s
- Players that Retired in the 1960s
- Players that Retired in the 1950s
- Players that Retired in the 1940s
- Players that Retired in the 1930s