Exciting MLB Trade Deadline Scenarios for 2025 Season

Baseball’s trade deadline is almost here, and the buzz is everywhere—fans, analysts, and front offices are all fired up about possible moves that could shake up MLB. With less than a week left, rumors are flying, and some wild predictions are just meant to stir the pot.

This post explores five hypothetical trade scenarios that could shake things up. None of these are based on confirmed reports—they’re just creative ideas to get people talking.

Scenario 1: The Red Sox Land Edward Cabrera in a Multi-Team Trade

The Boston Red Sox need starting pitching. Grabbing Edward Cabrera from the Miami Marlins might be their answer.

This trade idea goes further by bringing in the San Diego Padres for a three-team swap. Here’s how it could look:

• The Red Sox get Edward Cabrera to beef up their rotation.
• The Padres land Jarren Duran, adding speed and depth to their outfield.
• The Marlins pick up top prospects from both teams, setting themselves up for the future.

Why the Red Sox Need Cabrera

Cabrera brings swing-and-miss stuff and real upside. Boston’s rotation has been inconsistent, and a young, controllable arm could help their playoff push.

This kind of move fits with the Red Sox’s approach—they want to compete now but also think ahead.

Scenario 2: Cubs Acquire Mitch Keller from the Pirates

The Chicago Cubs could use another strong starter. Mitch Keller from the Pittsburgh Pirates might be the right fit.

Keller has shown flashes of being an ace, but Pittsburgh’s weak offense hasn’t helped him shine. This trade would send key reinforcements to the Pirates and a needed arm to the Cubs:

• The Cubs get Keller to steady their rotation.
• The Pirates receive Owen Caissie and Cristian Hernandez—two young players who could spark their lineup.

A Smart Bet for the Cubs

Chicago’s in a spot where adding someone like Keller just makes sense. His skillset lines up with their push to stay competitive in the NL Central.

For Pittsburgh, this trade brings in two promising, everyday players and gives their rebuild a shot in the arm.

Scenario 3: Yankees Solve Their Third Base Woes by Acquiring Maikel Garcia

The New York Yankees have struggled at third base. Maikel Garcia from the Kansas City Royals could fix that problem.

In this scenario, the Yankees would send outfield prospect Jasson Domínguez—a big-time young hitter—to the Royals. In return, Garcia, an All-Star who can hit and field, would shore up New York’s infield.

• The Yankees deal Domínguez to the Royals.
• They get Garcia, who brings both defense and offense to the table.

Garcia: A Perfect Fit for the Yankees

The Yankees haven’t found a steady third baseman, and Garcia is already handling pressure well in Kansas City. His glove and bat would immediately make New York better on both sides of the ball.

Scenario 4: The Dodgers Target Twins’ Elite Relievers

The Los Angeles Dodgers spent big on their bullpen this offseason, but maybe they’re still not done. They could look to the Minnesota Twins for more firepower.

This idea has the Dodgers landing Jhoan Duran, Griffin Jax, and Willi Castro. In exchange, Minnesota would get Josue De Paula—L.A.’s top prospect—and some more young talent.

• The Dodgers add Duran, Jax, and Castro to their roster.
• The Twins receive De Paula and other prospects to build for the future.

Twins’ Relievers Are Just What L.A. Needs

Duran and Jax could finally give the Dodgers some bullpen reliability. Pairing them with Castro’s versatility would be a big win for L.A.

Scenario 5: Reds Bring Power Back With Eugenio Suárez

The Cincinnati Reds want more power in their lineup. Why not bring back Eugenio Suárez in a trade with the Arizona Diamondbacks?

Here’s the basic idea: Cincinnati gets Suárez, who can hit for power and play infield. Arizona receives Cam Collier and a couple of young pitchers to boost their farm system.

• The Reds re-acquire Suárez for a playoff push.
• The Diamondbacks add depth and youth to their roster.

Suárez: A Familiar Face for the Reds

Suárez’s bat has always packed a punch, and honestly, a return to Cincinnati could light a fire under him again. The Reds want that big postseason push, so bringing in a seasoned slugger with some pop just makes sense.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Five MLB deadline trades I’d like to see, starting with a stunning three-team deal