Bo Bichette Seeks Second Opinion, Could Shift to DH Role

The Toronto Blue Jays are staring down a critical moment in their playoff chase. Star shortstop Bo Bichette is now seeking a second medical opinion on his sprained left knee.

Bichette’s bat is still one of the most dangerous in baseball. But nobody’s sure yet if he’s ready to play shortstop defensively, and that uncertainty is swirling as the season winds down.

With Toronto gunning for a deep postseason run, Bichette’s health is suddenly the talk of the town. Fans, analysts—everyone’s watching and wondering what happens next.

Bo Bichette’s Injury and Recovery Journey

Bichette, just 27, hurt his knee back on September 7 in a home plate collision with the Yankees. That play landed him on the 10-day injured list, retroactive to the day of the injury.

Since then, he’s been walking a fine line: trying to keep his bat sharp while working to regain his defensive range. It’s not exactly an easy balance, and you can feel the tension around his recovery.

On Monday, Bichette headed to Dallas for an exam with orthopedic specialist Dr. Dan Cooper. Manager John Schneider made it clear this was all planned—just part of the process, not because of any setback.

The Blue Jays’ front office sounds optimistic about his return. Still, they’re weighing their options and not rushing anything, which honestly feels wise given the stakes.

Designated Hitter Role a Possibility

Toronto’s coaches are considering slotting Bichette in as a designated hitter before putting him back at shortstop. Schneider mentioned that Bichette’s swing is looking good, but his lateral movement and agility—pretty critical for a shortstop—are lagging behind a bit.

This hybrid idea could get his bat back in the lineup sooner, which the Jays desperately need. At the same time, it would lower the risk of him making things worse with his knee.

A Career Season Cut Short — For Now

Before the injury, Bichette was tearing it up. He was putting up numbers that made him one of the best hitters in Major League Baseball.

In 139 games, here’s what he’s done so far:

• .311 batting average
• 18 home runs
• 94 RBIs
• .840 OPS

Maybe the wildest stat? Bichette leads the majors in both hits (181) and doubles (44). His steady presence at the plate has powered a Blue Jays offense that, honestly, has looked pretty intimidating most nights.

The Blue Jays’ Playoff Picture

Toronto’s down to the final 12 games of the regular season, sitting at 88-62 and leading the American League. They’ve got a five-game edge over the Yankees in the AL East—not a huge cushion, but enough to breathe a little.

Getting Bichette’s bat back, even if he’s not at shortstop, could be huge for locking down home-field advantage in the playoffs. It’s hard not to think his return might tip the scales.

The Bigger Picture for Toronto

The Jays haven’t made a deep postseason run in years, so the timing of Bichette’s return feels massive. The team’s medical and coaching staffs are working closely together to make sure Bichette is both effective and durable for what could be a long October.

Balancing Risk and Reward

The Jays need to decide if they should bring Bichette back as a DH or wait until he’s ready to play shortstop again. It’s a tough call—do you chase a quick offensive boost now, or play it safe for his long-term health?

In the postseason, every at-bat feels huge. Bichette’s bat could seriously change the vibe in any series.

Right now, everyone’s waiting for news from his Dallas check-up. Fans are hoping—maybe even a bit anxiously—that Bo gets back on the field soon. As Toronto pushes toward the finish, his health might be the biggest story in baseball.

—

If you want, I can dig into a **projected impact analysis** showing how Bichette’s return—even just as a DH—could shift Toronto’s playoff odds. Should I pull that together next?
 
Here is the source article for this story: Bichette (knee) seeks 2nd opinion, may move to DH