Yankees Off to Ugly Start in ALDS: Early Troubles Mount

The Toronto Blue Jays opened their Division Series with a loud 10–1 win over the New York Yankees at Rogers Centre. They flipped the script, using the Yankees’ own signature power and pitching against them.

From early home runs to shutdown pitching, Toronto made a statement. Now, New York is left scrambling for answers before Game 2 even arrives.

Blue Jays Set the Tone Early

Toronto wasted no time taking control. Yankees starter Luis Gil had looked sharp earlier in the postseason, but he just didn’t have it tonight.

He lasted only 2⅔ innings, serving up home runs to Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Alejandro Kirk before anyone in the stands could get comfortable. Those early blasts gave the Blue Jays a cushion they’d never give back.

Guerrero Jr. and Kirk Deliver the Damage

Guerrero’s homer set the tone, showing everyone why he’s one of the game’s top power hitters. Kirk followed up by crushing Gil’s fastball deep into the seats.

The Yankees couldn’t settle in defensively. That only added to the pressure and forced their bullpen into action long before they’d hoped.

Gausman Outduels Yankees’ Stars

On the mound, Kevin Gausman looked locked in. The veteran righty tossed five-plus innings, mixing blistering fastballs with nasty off-speed stuff.

Whenever the Yankees tried to rally, Gausman shut them down. He just didn’t give them much to work with.

Missed Opportunities by Judge and Stanton

The sixth inning felt like the Yankees’ chance. With the bases loaded, Aaron Judge struck out, unable to catch up to Gausman’s arsenal.

Then Giancarlo Stanton faced reliever Louis Varland, who fired a 100.7-mph fastball right past him to end the threat. That was probably it for New York’s hopes.

Yankees’ Offensive Struggles

New York’s bats just couldn’t get going. Their only run came on a bases-loaded walk to Cody Bellinger.

Outside of that, Toronto’s pitchers kept them off balance and forced awkward at-bats. The Yankees never looked comfortable at the plate.

Blue Jays’ Bullpen Slams the Door

After Gausman exited, Toronto’s bullpen took over and didn’t let up. Over the final 3⅓ innings, they allowed no runs and gave the Yankees no room to breathe.

Every pitch felt like it was designed to shut down any late-game drama. The Yankees never threatened again.

Collapse in the Seventh

The seventh inning sealed it for New York. Luke Weaver and Fernando Cruz gave up four runs between them.

Weaver later admitted he might’ve tipped his pitches, which is a rough look for any reliever in October. That’s got to shake his confidence a bit.

Confidence Issues in the Yankees’ Bullpen

When relievers start doubting their mechanics under pressure, things can spiral. Weaver’s comments hint that the Yankees are facing more than just tactical problems.

They’re dealing with some psychological hurdles, too. That could haunt them as the series continues.

Looking Ahead to Game 2

Down 0–1, the Yankees have little time to regroup. They’ll hand the ball to Max Fried in Game 2, hoping his playoff experience steadies things.

Toronto counters with rookie Trey Yesavage, who’s making his postseason debut. It’s a classic matchup—veteran ace against a rising young arm. Should be interesting to see how that plays out.

Keys to a Yankees Bounce-Back

For New York to even the series, a few things really need to click:

• Early offensive production – They can’t let themselves fall behind before the bullpen even gets involved.
• Executing with runners in scoring position – Blowing chances like they did in Game 1 just can’t happen again.
• Stabilizing the bullpen – The relievers have to shake off any mechanical hiccups and regain some confidence, especially late.

Game 1 stung. The Yankees saw firsthand that the Blue Jays can go toe-to-toe with them, both on the mound and at the plate.

If New York doesn’t adjust fast, Toronto could run away with this Division Series. That wouldn’t sit well with anyone in pinstripes.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Yankees off to ugly start in Division Series