Brewers Present Mets Perfect Plan B if Skubal Pursuit Fails

The New York Mets are at another crossroads, staring down a rebuild after a late-season collapse. Their main offseason goal? Land a real ace to lead the rotation.

The front office dreams big with Detroit Tigers’ star Tarik Skubal at the top of their list. Still, they know he might be too expensive, so they’re eyeing other options—like Milwaukee Brewers right-hander Freddy Peralta, a proven All-Star heading into a pivotal year.

Mets’ Pursuit of Pitching Power

Pitching wins championships, and the Mets know it. After September’s meltdown, they desperately need a durable, dominant starter.

Tarik Skubal is the dream. The Detroit lefty is a Cy Young contender, with a nasty strikeout arsenal and sharp command.

The Challenge of Landing Tarik Skubal

Skubal’s age and talent make him a unicorn. He’s not just good now—he’ll be a force for years.

Detroit will want a king’s ransom: top prospects, young talent, the works. He’s under contract until 2026, so the price won’t be cheap.

The Mets have to ask themselves: How much are they willing to give up for an ace?

Freddy Peralta: A More Attainable Option

Skubal’s appeal is obvious, but Freddy Peralta brings a nice mix of talent and affordability. The Brewers’ righty isn’t as controllable long-term, but he’s a two-time All-Star coming off a career year.

Peralta just finished with a 17–6 record, 2.70 ERA, 1.075 WHIP, and 204 strikeouts. He showed dominance and stayed consistent all year.

Why Milwaukee Might Trade Peralta

The Brewers, running on a small-market budget, often have to make tough calls when players near free agency. Peralta’s entering the final year of a $15.5 million deal, set to make $8 million in 2025, and he’ll want a big payday soon.

Given their payroll limits, Milwaukee might trade him now to get value before he walks.

How the Mets Could Seal the Deal

The Mets have two big advantages if they chase Peralta: a strong farm system and team president David Stearns. Stearns knows the Brewers inside out from his time as their GM.

This could make talks smoother and boost the odds of a deal.

Age and Impact Factor

Peralta is just 29, right in his prime. His fastball-slider combo and knack for missing bats fit the Mets’ needs perfectly.

Bringing him in would strengthen their rotation and send a clear message—they’re aiming for the top in 2025.

Weighing the Cost-Benefit Equation

Chasing Skubal means giving up a lot of prospects but possibly locking in an ace for years. Peralta would cost less in assets and still offer front-line results, though for a shorter time.

This decision will shape the Mets’ offseason strategy.

• Skubal: Elite, long-term control, sky-high acquisition cost.
• Peralta: Proven All-Star, shorter-term contract, more affordable trade package.
• Both would upgrade the rotation in a big way.

What This Means for Mets Fans

This offseason will test fans’ patience and perspective. Do they want the blockbuster move that could reshape the franchise, or a smart trade for a reliable ace who brings instant stability?

Either way, the Mets look ready to make some noise.

The Road Ahead

Free agency and trade talks are heating up. The Mets’ front office is hustling to make sure September’s letdown doesn’t happen again.

Maybe it’ll be Tarik Skubal or Freddy Peralta wearing orange and blue on Opening Day. Honestly, 2025 feels like it’ll depend on how well they rebuild the top of their rotation.

Pitching wins championships—no way around it. For the Mets, this winter’s choices might finally be the turning point they’ve needed.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Brewers Rumor Offers Mets Perfect Plan B if Tarik Skubal Pursuit Fails