Yankees Should Pick Cody Bellinger Over Cubs Star

The New York Yankees are staring down one of the toughest choices of their offseason. Should they re-sign dynamic slugger Cody Bellinger, or chase Houston Astros star Kyle Tucker instead?

Both players put up strong numbers in 2025. The Yankees’ front office has to weigh offensive output, defensive value, and contract demands to figure out who fits their long-term plans best.

Industry insiders seem to lean toward Bellinger. They cite his consistency, adaptability, and how well his game matches Yankee Stadium’s quirks—so this decision could shape the team’s future in a big way.

Why Executives Favor Cody Bellinger

People around the league see Bellinger as more than just a good hitter. He fits the Yankees’ offensive philosophy and seems built for their ballpark.

Consistency and Predictability

Lots of stars have up-and-down years, but Bellinger has steadied his approach in the last three seasons. In 2025, he delivered a .272 batting average, 29 home runs, 98 RBIs, and a solid 4.9 fWAR.

That kind of steady production is exactly what the Yankees need. They’re always hunting for reliable offense, especially in the late months.

Defensive Versatility

Another thing that draws execs to Bellinger? He can handle several positions. He covers the outfield and can fill in at first base when needed.

This kind of flexibility gives the Yankees some breathing room when injuries pop up or the roster needs a shake-up. Baseball loves players who can move around, and Bellinger’s versatility stands out.

Kyle Tucker’s Offensive Edge—and Defensive Decline

Kyle Tucker still brings serious offensive firepower. He’s one of the most disciplined hitters out there, and his 2025 numbers prove it: .841 OPS, 22 home runs, and 25 stolen bases, with a 4.5 fWAR.

Concerns About Defensive Metrics

But Tucker’s defense in right field slipped last year. That’s not great news for a franchise like the Yankees, who’ve always cared about strong fielding to back up their big bats.

In tight playoff games, every defensive play matters. Any lapses could come back to haunt them.

The Financial Factor

Money’s always part of the equation. Tucker is expected to demand a much higher salary in free agency than Bellinger.

Even though both are in their primes, the Yankees might get Bellinger for less cash without losing much production. With luxury tax thresholds always looming, saving on salary means they can use that money elsewhere.

Cost-Effective Stability

Re-signing Bellinger would give the Yankees a proven, steady performer at a lower price. That keeps them flexible for upgrades—maybe a better bullpen, more infield depth, or a veteran leader on the bench.

This mix of performance and smart spending is why so many execs call Bellinger the “safer” bet.

The Yankees’ Potential Pivot Plan

If Bellinger goes elsewhere, sources say the Yankees will take a serious look at Tucker. His lefty bat and speed would give their lineup a new twist.

But if they have to pick right now, the word around the league is pretty clear: Bellinger just fits better.

Key Takeaways for Yankees Fans

• Bellinger brings a strong mix of offense and defensive flexibility.
• Tucker still swings a big bat, but his defense has slipped.
• Bellinger comes at a better price.
• The Yankees will only chase Tucker if Bellinger’s off the table.

The Yankees’ front office faces a big decision as the offseason ramps up. Their choice could shape the team’s future for years.

Tradition matters here, but so does smart spending. It’s about finding the right mix of performance, adaptability, and value.

Right now, Cody Bellinger looks like the guy who checks those boxes.

—
 
Here is the source article for this story: Yankees Urged to Pick Cody Bellinger Over Cubs Star