Padres’ Yu Darvish Unsure About Return After Third Elbow Surgery

The future of Yu Darvish, one of the most accomplished pitchers of his generation, is hanging in the balance after yet another serious elbow surgery.

As the San Diego Padres and their fans look ahead to 2025 and beyond, the franchise icon is caught between a relentless drive to compete and the realities of a 39-year-old arm that’s absorbed more punishment than most careers can handle.

Yu Darvish Faces an Uncertain MLB Future After Third Elbow Surgery

In late October, Darvish had surgery to repair a torn flexor tendon and damage to his ulnar collateral ligament in his right elbow.

Doctors say the recovery timeline is long and unforgiving, with estimates suggesting he could be sidelined through at least 2027—if he returns at all.

At this point, Darvish isn’t promising a comeback.

He’s made it clear: his focus is entirely on rehabilitation, not on circling a date for a return to the mound.

For a player whose career has been all about precision, adaptation, and durability at the highest level, that admission shows just how serious this setback really is.

A Major Surgery at a Critical Stage of His Career

Elbow discomfort had already delayed Darvish’s planned 2025 season debut until July.

When he did pitch, the results were troubling—over 15 starts, he posted a career-worst 5.38 ERA, far from the standard he’s set since his MLB debut in 2012.

This latest procedure follows a long injury history:

All of that damage has led to this crossroads, where even a competitor as proud and meticulous as Darvish has to wonder if his body can really endure another long climb back.

The Contract Question: $46 Million and a Possible Buyout

On top of the medical concerns, there’s a big financial storyline here.

Darvish is in the middle of a six-year, $108 million contract extension he signed with the Padres in 2023, with $46 million still owed.

He’s admitted—both privately and publicly—that retirement has been on his mind as injuries have piled up.

If he decides to walk away, it’s likely the Padres and Darvish would talk about a buyout to restructure the remaining money.

How Retirement Would Impact the Padres

If Darvish retires, the Padres would gain some payroll flexibility.

But they’d also lose a veteran workhorse they hoped would anchor the rotation deep into this decade.

His contract was structured with the expectation he’d provide both innings and leadership, and any early exit would force the front office to revisit long-term rotation plans.

The organization isn’t pushing the decision. The tone from the top has been steady: Darvish has earned the right to set his own timeline.

Beyond the Box Score: Darvish’s Impact in the Clubhouse

Even though his recent stat lines don’t look like his prime, Darvish’s value to the Padres stretches way beyond his ERA.

Inside the organization, he’s seen as a teacher, strategist, and culture-setter, especially for the younger pitchers.

Pitchers like Randy Vásquez have credited Darvish for helping them navigate the steep learning curve of major league pitching.

Whether it’s pitch design, game planning, or the mental side of handling failure, Darvish’s fingerprints are all over the Padres’ pitching room.

Padres Expect Darvish to Stay Involved

Team president A.J. Preller and new manager Craig Stammen have both said they want Darvish around, no matter his playing status.

That could mean informal mentoring during rehab, a more defined advisory role, or maybe even the first steps toward a future in coaching or player development.

In a sport that’s obsessed with data, Darvish’s rare mix of analytical curiosity and real on-field experience makes him a perfect bridge between the front office and the clubhouse.

A Legacy Already Secure, Even if This Is the End

Whatever happens next, Darvish’s legacy isn’t in question.

A five-time All-Star and two-time Cy Young Award runner-up, he’s put together a resume that stands among the best of his era.

He holds the record for the most combined wins by a Japanese-born pitcher.

Since his MLB arrival in 2012, he ranks sixth all-time in strikeouts over that span. Those numbers put him in elite company, and honestly, it’s hard to argue with his place as one of the most dominant and creative pitchers of the modern game.

What Comes Next for Yu Darvish?

Right now, there’s no set return date. Instead, Darvish faces the daily grind of rehab—strength training, stretching, and, at some point, those first careful throws.

He’ll find out soon enough if another run on the mound is in the cards. Whether he decides to push for one more comeback or finally calls it, his mark on the Padres and MLB is already set in stone.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Padres’ Yu Darvish unsure if he will pitch again after third elbow surgery