Aaron Judge Deserves Better Than Michael Jordan Comparison

Absolutely — I’ll take those summarized points and turn them into a compelling, **SEO-friendly professional sports column**, making it engaging, informative, and optimized for search. I’ll weave in some history, a bit of narrative, and tie it all to today’s sports debates. Here’s the reworked blog post:

—

The MVP voting debate? It’s about as old as the award itself. History keeps warning us about the trap of chasing novelty instead of sticking with true greatness.

Look at Michael Jordan in the 1990s. His dominant run is probably the clearest example of how voter fatigue can rob a legendary athlete of the credit they deserve. Jordan missed out on extra MVP trophies because voters, hungry for something new, wanted fresh storylines.

We’re seeing the same risk now with stars like Aaron Judge in Major League Baseball. It’s not just a sports debate—it’s a reminder that even the best can get overlooked when people crave change more than consistency.

The Legacy of Michael Jordan’s MVP Battles

Rewind to Jordan’s career. He picked up five NBA Most Valuable Player awards, but plenty of experts would argue he probably earned at least seven. His year-after-year dominance just didn’t let up.

By the early ’90s, though, voters started showing signs of voter fatigue. They seemed to get tired of the same story, even if that story was historic brilliance.

1993: Barkley’s Turn for the Spotlight

Check out the 1993 season. Jordan had just won back-to-back MVPs in ’91 and ’92, leading the Bulls to titles and putting up wild numbers. But when the MVP votes came in for ’93, Charles Barkley got the nod.

Barkley absolutely deserved recognition—he led the Suns to 62 wins. Still, you can’t help but feel the decision was about more than just the stats. Voters wanted a new headline, a different face for the award.

The Karl Malone Episode

Fast-forward to 1997. Same story. Jordan, still the league’s best, got passed over again—this time for Karl Malone. Jordan’s numbers dazzled as usual, but the voters seemed to want a change in the narrative.

It wasn’t just about the box score. It was about shaking things up, even if everyone knew who the best player was.

“Ho-Hum, He’s Great Again” Mentality

Voters watched Jordan dominate year after year until it started to feel routine. That’s where this “ho-hum, he’s great again” attitude crept in.

Instead of celebrating his consistency, voters got bored. They searched for novelty just to keep things interesting. It’s a weird psychological trap, honestly.

The Broader Lesson for Modern MVP Voting

This whole saga still matters, especially now. Look at today’s MVP races in other sports—like baseball’s Aaron Judge. Judge brings ridiculous power, leadership, and keeps showing up as an MVP candidate. But once voters give him the award, will they start looking elsewhere just for the sake of change?

Why Voter Fatigue Is So Persistent

The MVP award always mixes cold stats with a splash of emotional narrative. Voters want fresh heroes, underdog stories, and dramatic comebacks. Sure, those stories add flavor, but sometimes they overshadow what really counts: picking the player who’s actually most valuable that year.

Just like with Jordan, voters can end up penalizing greatness just because it starts to look easy or predictable.

Key Takeaways for Fans and Analysts

The Jordan case really says a lot about sports in general. If we care about excellence, then consistency matters more than flashy new stories.

We shouldn’t need a fresh narrative just to recognize someone’s ongoing dominance.

• Sustained greatness deserves celebration, not punishment.
• Narratives make sports coverage more interesting, but performance should always come first.
• Historical perspective helps us avoid repeating mistakes in voting.

MVP races are heating up again. Remember what happened with Michael Jordan—he lost out on awards simply because people got used to his greatness.

If Aaron Judge or any other superstar keeps performing at a high level, voters really should judge each season on its own. Let’s not let boredom with dominance get in the way of fairness or history.

—

If you want, I can put together **meta descriptions, keyword ideas, and internal linking tips** to help this post show up higher in Google searches and reach both baseball and basketball fans. Just let me know if you’re interested.
 
Here is the source article for this story: Aaron Judge deserves better than the Michael Jordan treatment —…