Bregman Rumors: Red Sox, D-Backs, Tigers and Cubs Linked

Alex Bregman’s free agency has taken another unexpected turn. What started as a relatively clean market with a few aggressive suitors has shifted. Roster moves, payroll realities, and changing priorities across the league are shaking things up.

Toronto now seems to have stepped aside. Familiar contenders are cooling off, and suddenly Bregman’s next contract is one of the offseason’s most fascinating storylines.

The Blue Jays’ Pivot Changes the Market

Earlier this winter, the Toronto Blue Jays looked like front-runners for Bregman. That changed fast when Toronto signed Japanese star third baseman Kazuma Okamoto.

With Okamoto in the fold, a clean positional fit for Bregman disappeared. Maybe a creative alignment with Bo Bichette could reopen talks, but it doesn’t seem likely right now.

This move signals Toronto isn’t aggressively chasing Bregman anymore. The field narrows, and what looked like a three- or four-team race now feels much more concentrated.

Everyone left in the mix feels more pressure—and maybe a little more leverage.

Why Toronto Made Sense—and Why It No Longer Does

Bregman’s right-handed bat, playoff experience, and leadership lined up with Toronto’s window to compete. Okamoto’s arrival changes that calculus.

The Jays now have cost certainty and long-term control at third base, something Bregman’s free agency can’t really offer. Unless Toronto shakes up its infield, it looks like they’ve moved on.

Boston Remains the Central Figure

Boston’s still here, steady as ever. ESPN’s Buster Olney reported that the Red Sox might already have an offer on the table.

It could be a long-term, high-dollar deal, maybe similar to what Detroit reportedly proposed last winter. The Red Sox once signed Bregman to a creative three-year contract loaded with opt-outs and deferrals.

That deal pushed his average annual value to about $40 million, while minimizing Boston’s short-term cash outlay.

A Shift in Bregman’s Priorities

Bregman’s now 31 and heading into his age-32 season. His outlook has changed—short-term deals with opt-outs aren’t as appealing when long-term security starts to matter more.

This winter might be his best—and maybe last—chance to land a fully guaranteed, multi-year commitment.

Boston’s creative approach to contracts puts them in a unique spot. If ownership’s comfortable with the length and guarantees Bregman wants, they could make it work.

Arizona: The Most Legitimate Challenger

With Toronto out of the picture, the Arizona Diamondbacks have emerged as Boston’s most credible challenger. Arizona’s interest is tied closely to Ketel Marte’s uncertain future.

Most league chatter suggests Bregman’s only a real target if Marte gets moved. But general manager Mike Hazen recently hinted Marte might be staying put, which complicates things.

Payroll, Not Talent, Is the Issue

On the field, Arizona could fit both players. The financial side is trickier.

The Diamondbacks already committed $102.5 million to Marte. Ownership might hesitate to add another nine-figure deal to the infield.

Maybe the 2026 cash flow works out, but the long-term payroll could make Arizona think twice.

Detroit and Chicago Fade Into the Background

Last winter’s aggressive suitors have cooled off. The Tigers once loomed large in Bregman talks, but now they seem reluctant to jump back into the long-term market after raising their payroll.

The Chicago Cubs are still hanging around the edges. They offered four years and $115 million last offseason, but lately they’ve shown more confidence in younger internal options like Matt Shaw.

Why the Cubs Are Unlikely to Push All-In

Public comments from Cubs executives make it clear they’re not looking to top the highest bidders. Their focus on player development keeps them in the background.

Chicago looks more like a contingency plan than a real contender for Bregman at this point.

A Market Defined by Uncertainty

At this stage, Alex Bregman’s free agency isn’t really about how many teams are interested. It’s more about which team actually makes sense for him.

Boston and Arizona keep coming up in conversations. Meanwhile, Detroit and Chicago seem to have faded into the background.

Bregman’s next contract will say a lot about what he values. He wants stability, not just a big payday.

The Red Sox, right now, look like the team most likely to give him what he’s after.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Bregman Rumors: Red Sox, D-Backs, Tigers, Cubs