Guardians’ Stephen Vogt Wins Back-to-Back AL Manager of the Year

This blog post dives into the historic achievement of Cleveland Guardians manager Stephen Vogt, who just picked up the 2025 American League Manager of the Year award for the second year in a row. That’s a pretty big deal for any manager, let alone someone as new to the gig as Vogt.

His back-to-back wins place him among a pretty exclusive group of AL skippers. Over in the National League, Pat Murphy of the Milwaukee Brewers pulled off the same feat, so both leagues ended up with repeat winners in the same year. When’s the last time that happened? Never, actually. It’s a first.

Stephen Vogt Joins Elite Company

Winning Manager of the Year twice in a row in the American League is almost unheard of. Vogt is now just the second AL manager to do it, after Kevin Cash led the Tampa Bay Rays to consecutive honors in 2020 and 2021.

This accomplishment really highlights Vogt’s knack for leadership. He’s shown he can keep up with, and even outsmart, some of the sharpest minds in the game.

Cleveland’s Sixth Manager of the Year Award

The Guardians have a real track record of strong managers. Vogt’s latest win adds to those by Terry Francona (2013, 2016, 2022) and Eric Wedge (2007), bringing the franchise total to six.

That’s not too shabby. Clearly, Cleveland values stability and a long-term vision when it comes to who’s calling the shots.

The 2025 Voting Results

This year’s vote showed just how deep the pool of AL managerial talent runs. The Baseball Writers’ Association of America used a 5-3-1 point system for first, second, and third-place votes, with all ballots submitted before the postseason.

Vogt ended up with:

• 17 first-place votes
• 8 second-place votes
• 4 third-place votes
• Total: 113 points

The 30 ballots—two from each American League city—didn’t produce a unanimous winner. That just goes to show how many managers had seasons worth talking about.

Close Competition for the Award

Runner-up John Schneider of the Toronto Blue Jays finished with 91 points. That’s the best finish for a Blue Jays manager since Cito Gaston way back in 1989.

Toronto’s only Manager of the Year winner remains Bobby Cox from 1985. Third place went to Dan Wilson (Seattle Mariners, 50 points), with Alex Cora (Boston Red Sox), A.J. Hinch (Detroit Tigers), and Joe Espada (Houston Astros) rounding out the list.

National League History Made Too

Vogt wasn’t the only one making headlines. Pat Murphy of the Milwaukee Brewers repeated as Manager of the Year in the NL.

This marks the first time both leagues crowned back-to-back winners in the same year. It’s kind of wild, considering how often teams swap out their managers these days.

What Makes Back-to-Back Wins Special

Baseball’s unpredictable. Injuries, trades, slumps—there’s always something that can mess up a season. So when a manager wins this award two years running, it really says something about their adaptability and steady hand.

It’s not just about tactics. It’s about keeping a team together, even when the roster keeps changing.

The Significance for Cleveland’s Future

For the Guardians, Vogt’s award isn’t just a personal milestone. It’s a sign the organization’s moving in the right direction.

Having a manager who keeps winning helps with everything—player trust, free agent interest, and, honestly, fan hope. Maybe this is just the beginning.

Final Thoughts

The 2025 American League Manager of the Year award really cements Stephen Vogt as one of baseball’s brightest managerial talents. He’s joined an exclusive club of repeat winners.

Alongside Pat Murphy’s NL triumph, this season stands out as one of those rare moments in pro baseball history where both leagues got a real taste of leadership stability. Cleveland’s ongoing success with Vogt at the helm could be one of the most interesting storylines to follow as we head into 2026.

—

If you’d like, I can also provide an **SEO-friendly meta description** for this blog post that will help boost its search engine performance. Would you like me to do that?
 
Here is the source article for this story: Guardians’ Stephen Vogt wins back-to-back AL Manager of the Year awards