Mariners Prioritize Re-Signing Josh Naylor in 2025 Free Agency

The Seattle Mariners’ 2025 campaign ended in dramatic and disappointing fashion. They battled for seven games in the ALCS but ultimately fell short against the Toronto Blue Jays.

With emotions still raw, the Mariners now pivot toward a critical offseason. This stretch could redefine their roster and change the team’s trajectory.

President of Baseball Operations Jerry Dipoto faces a tricky blend of contractual priorities and roster realignment. The front office wants to capture the momentum from one of Seattle’s closest brushes with the World Series.

Josh Naylor Tops Mariners’ Offseason Wishlist

Josh Naylor sits squarely at the top of Seattle’s wish list. The Mariners acquired him midseason from the Arizona Diamondbacks, and he completely transformed the team’s offense.

Naylor’s final stat line—.299/.341/.490 with 19 stolen bases over just 54 games—shows his adaptability and knack for clutch moments. He made a real impact when it mattered most.

Why Naylor Fits Seattle’s Offensive Vision

Naylor’s skill set fits Seattle’s long-standing goal: cut down strikeouts and boost contact quality. Few players today mix consistent contact, extra-base power, and speed as well as he does.

He’s just 28, and since he’s not tied to a qualifying offer, negotiations won’t get bogged down. Naylor will probably get a multi-year offer—think four to six years, and it’ll likely surpass any free-agent position player deal in Mariners history.

Dipoto has made his admiration for Naylor clear, especially for two reasons:

• Naylor’s shown he can produce in pitcher-friendly T-Mobile Park.
• He’s built a solid bond with Seattle fans, who love his energy and versatility.

Payroll Flexibility Creates Opportunity

Seattle’s payroll projections offer real optimism. With about $139 million committed for next year—well under their 2025 ending figure of $166 million—they’ve got room to pursue top talent.

This flexibility means the Mariners can prioritize Naylor and still address other roster needs. No need to blow past budget constraints just to make moves.

Jorge Polanco: A Candidate for Short-Term Retention

Jorge Polanco remains firmly in the mix alongside Naylor. The veteran infielder bounced back this season, batting .265/.326/.495 with 26 home runs.

He turns 33 next July, but Polanco’s steady bat and ability to play multiple positions make him a strong candidate for a short-term deal. The plan? Use him as a designated hitter and part-time infielder while prospect Cole Young gets ready for a full-time role.

Looking Beyond Familiar Faces

Not every big name is likely to return. The Mariners seem ready to move on from third baseman Eugenio Suárez.

His age and declining numbers line up with the rise of prospects Colt Emerson and Ben Williamson. Seattle’s leaning into a philosophy that balances veteran leadership with emerging young talent.

Prospect Power in the Pipeline

By making room for players like Emerson and Williamson, Seattle’s betting on internal development. They need young, controllable talent to keep the roster dynamic and the books balanced.

The Road Ahead for Seattle

The Mariners’ end-of-season press conference will shape their offseason strategy. Expect Dipoto and the front office to address:

• How big and long a Naylor extension could be.
• Polanco’s role in 2026 and beyond.
• Prospect promotions and changes in the infield.
• Potential free-agent targets outside the current roster.

Aiming for the Final Leap

Seattle’s near miss in 2025 stirs up both frustration and a bit of hope. The ALCS events have really hammered home what this team’s all about—pitching depth, clutch hitting, and a defense that can flex as needed.

Now the real challenge? Turning that identity into something that actually gets them a championship. With the right mix of keeping savvy vets and letting the kids play, maybe—just maybe—the Mariners are finally on the verge of breaking through to baseball’s biggest stage.

For Mariners fans, the 2025 offseason isn’t just about plugging gaps. It’s about building a team that can actually take that last, stubborn step.

There’s some room in the budget, Naylor’s become the clear offensive spark, and a few young stars look ready for their shot. Seattle’s blueprint for success feels closer than it has in ages—maybe this is what finally gets the city what it’s been waiting for.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Mariners Will Prioritize Josh Naylor In Free Agency