Mets Trade Grades: Analyzing Tyler Rogers’ Value in Deadline Deal

The New York Mets and San Francisco Giants made headlines just hours before the MLB trade deadline. They pulled off a four-player swap that could shake things up for both teams.

The Mets picked up veteran reliever Tyler Rogers. Meanwhile, the Giants landed right-handers José Buttó and Blade Tidwell, plus outfielder Drew Gilbert.

With playoffs in mind, the Mets wanted to shore up their bullpen. The Giants, on the other hand, seem to be betting on upside and future returns.

Breaking Down the Trade: What the Mets and Giants Are Gaining

Tyler Rogers is the big name here for New York. At 34, he doesn’t blow hitters away, but he has a knack for getting weak contact—something you can’t teach.

Since the start of 2023, Rogers has a 151 ERA+, which puts him among MLB’s top 25 relievers. The Mets already have stars like Edwin Díaz and Gregory Soto, but Rogers adds something extra to their mix.

How Tyler Rogers Fits Into the Mets’ Strategy

The Mets wanted to make the most of their 40-man roster. They traded players on the edge of their roster for a proven bullpen arm.

With a playoff push underway, Rogers gives them a steady hand for tough spots late in games. He fits right in with a bullpen that’s had its ups and downs this season.

If you’re wondering how Rogers helps the Mets, here’s a quick rundown:

• Weak Contact Mastery: Rogers keeps hitters from making solid contact, which is huge in tight games.
• Reliable Under Pressure: His numbers show he can handle stressful situations and still get outs.
• Bolstered Relief Corps: Now, with Rogers joining Díaz, Raley, and Soto, the Mets have a deep bullpen for the late innings.

What the Giants Gain: Potential Over Proven Talent

The Giants took a different approach, focusing on players with upside. Buttó, Tidwell, and Gilbert are more about promise than track record.

Fans and analysts are already debating if any of these guys will turn into real contributors. It’s not clear yet, honestly.

The Profiles of Buttó, Tidwell, and Gilbert

Here’s a closer look at what San Francisco picked up:

• José Buttó: He’s 27 and can pitch multiple innings. With a 125 ERA+ since 2023, he’s durable but might end up in a smaller role if he can’t stay consistent.
• Blade Tidwell: At 24, Tidwell shows flashes with his pitch mix. But his command issues and struggles in limited MLB time make his future a real question mark.
• Drew Gilbert: Almost 25, Gilbert is a Triple-A outfielder with some notable splits. He might fit as a situational hitter, but it’s tough to say if he’ll stick in the majors.

The Giants are clearly thinking long-term with these guys. If Tidwell figures it out, this deal could look a lot better for San Francisco.

A Deal Worth Watching

At first glance, this trade seems unbalanced. Rogers has proven himself in the majors, while the Giants’ return looks untested.

But trades don’t exist in a vacuum. As the season rolls on, we’ll get to see how Rogers performs with the Mets and whether Buttó, Tidwell, and Gilbert make an impact for the Giants.

Both teams stuck to their philosophies. The Mets want to win right now. The Giants are betting on the future.

Who actually wins? I guess we’ll just have to wait and see.

Got an opinion about this deadline deal? Drop your thoughts in the comments below!

 
Here is the source article for this story: Tyler Rogers trade grades: Why Mets didn’t actually overpay for Giants reliever in MLB deadline deal