The MLB All-Star Game usually brings together the best of Major League Baseball. But if you look back, you’ll find some odd, even forgotten names who got their shot under the big lights.
This blog digs into those stories—the players who somehow became All-Stars, thanks to things like team needs, the quirks of fan voting, or just a lucky hot streak before July. Sometimes, it really was just a matter of being in the right place at the right time.
Frankie Zak: The Wartime Wonder
Let’s talk about Frankie Zak, the Pittsburgh Pirates shortstop who made the 1944 All-Star team. World War II left teams scrambling for players, and Zak grabbed the chance, even though his MLB career lasted only 123 games.
He wasn’t exactly a household name, but local circumstances worked in his favor. It goes to show, sometimes even the least-expected guys get their moment.
Overcoming Adversity: Eddie Kazak’s Inspirational Journey
Eddie Kazak found his way into the 1949 All-Star Game for a different reason. He served in World War II and came back from a shattered elbow to play for the St. Louis Cardinals.
Kazak even started the midsummer classic. His career didn’t last long, but you can’t help but respect the resilience it took for him to get there.
An Unlikely Lineup of Stars
Every so often, the All-Star Game features players who catch fire for just a few months—or just happen to be in the right place. Here are a few:
- John Romano (C, 1961) – He rode a hot start all the way to an All-Star spot.
- Justin Smoak (1B, 2017) – A monster first half put him on the map, but he didn’t keep it up for long.
- Orlando Arcia (SS, 2023) – His selection left plenty of fans scratching their heads.
These guys weren’t regular All-Stars, but for a moment, they got their due. It’s wild how quickly things can change in baseball.
The Anonymous All-Stars
Some players get their 15 minutes in the All-Star spotlight and then fade away. Kosuke Fukudome started the 2008 game as a rookie after a red-hot start, and Corey Dickerson made it in 2017, even though he bounced around teams most of his career.
There’s also Steve Swisher (C, 1976) and Bryan LaHair (1B, 2012), whose All-Star appearances are pretty much trivia fodder now. Baseball’s unpredictability is part of what makes it fun, isn’t it?
Statistical Oddities: Among the Worst Ever?
Not every All-Star was a statistical powerhouse. Some, honestly, were among the weakest to ever make the roster:
- Billy Hunter (SS, 1953) – He’s remembered more for his weak bat than his All-Star nod.
- Myril Hoag (OF, 1939) – His WAR was historically low, yet he still got the call.
It’s weird, but sometimes a fast start or the need to represent every team outweighs a whole season’s worth of stats.
Pitcher Spotlights: From Mediocrity to Stardom
Pitchers have their own share of odd All-Star stories. Dave Stenhouse (SP, 1962) and Mark Redman (SP, 2006) both made it despite pretty average seasons.
Maybe it’s just a matter of who’s left, or maybe it’s luck. Either way, the All-Star Game has room for a few surprises every year.
A Celebration of Baseball’s Forgotten Faces
The MLB All-Star Game is supposed to celebrate the best of the best. But if you dig into its history, you’ll find a record of baseball’s unexpected heroes too.
Think about wartime picks like Frankie Zak. Or breakout stars like Corey Dickerson. The All-Star stage has a way of shining a light on players who burned bright for just a moment, earning a place in the story even if most folks don’t remember their names now.
Most people picture All-Stars as legends, the elite. Yet these oddball selections remind us that baseball always leaves room for surprises.
Every roster rule, fan vote, or hot start can toss a player into that midsummer spotlight. The quirks of All-Star picks still spark debates—what does it actually mean to be “one of the best” anyway?
Here is the source article for this story: The most obscure MLB All-Stars ever: World War II fill-ins, a shortstop with a 37 OPS+ and … this year’s Rockies rep
Experience Baseball History in Person
Want to walk the same grounds where baseball legends made history? Find accommodations near iconic ballparks across America and create your own baseball pilgrimage.
Check availability at hotels near: Yankee Stadium, Fenway Park, Wrigley Field, Dodger Stadium
Plan your ballpark visit: Get MLB Ballpark Tickets and find accommodations nearby.
- Biographies
- Stadium Guides
- Current Baseball Players
- Current Players by Team
- Players that Retired in the 2020s
- Players that Retired in the 2010s
- Players that Retired in the 2000s
- Players that Retired in the 1990s
- Players that Retired in the 1980s
- Players that Retired in the 1970s
- Players that Retired in the 1960s
- Players that Retired in the 1950s
- Players that Retired in the 1940s
- Players that Retired in the 1930s