Sam Jones, better known as “Toothpick Sam” for his habit of pitching with a toothpick in his mouth, put together a truly remarkable 14-year professional baseball career. He played in both the Negro Leagues and Major League Baseball before hanging up his cleats in 1964.
Jones made history as the first African American pitcher to throw a no-hitter in Major League Baseball, pulling it off against the Pittsburgh Pirates on May 12, 1955. His journey took him from the Cleveland Buckeyes of the Negro Leagues to six different MLB teams—a testament to both his talent and the kind of grit that defined players of his era.
Born in Stewartsville, Ohio, Jones grew into one of the most feared pitchers of the 1950s and early 1960s. His curveball was so nasty that Hall of Famer Stan Musial called it the best he’d ever seen.
Jones led the National League in strikeouts three times. He had his best season with the San Francisco Giants in 1959, winning 21 games and leading the league in ERA.
His story really captures the transition from segregated baseball to the integrated big leagues. From his first days in the Negro Leagues to his final season with the Baltimore Orioles, Jones left a mark on the game that went way beyond just stats.
Sam Jones: Early Life and Background
Samuel Jones came into the world on December 14, 1925, in Stewartsville, Ohio. He faced a tough family situation early on, which shaped his character and determination.
He didn’t start playing baseball as early as most, instead beginning with military service during World War II before finding his way to the Negro Leagues.
Childhood and Upbringing
Samuel Jones was actually born Daniel Pore Franklin in Stewartsville, Ohio. His mother, Athelestine Jones, came from Alabama and was just a teenager when Sam arrived.
His father, John Franklin, left the family by 1930. Sam’s grandfather, Charles Jones, worked as a loader in the local coal mines and became the main father figure in his life.
When Sam was between 10 and 12, the family moved to West Virginia. Monongah, a coal mining town, became their new home, and his grandfather kept working in those dangerous mines.
Tragedy hit when Sam turned 13. His grandfather died in a mine explosion, and that loss left a deep mark on Sam. It really pushed him to look for a different path in life.
Sam went to Fairmont High School and played football and basketball. Still, he left school early and barely had any exposure to organized baseball as a kid.
Entry Into Baseball
Sam joined the Army around 1943 and got stationed in Orlando, Florida during World War II. He served at the Orlando Army Air Base and also at Pinecastle Army Air Field nearby.
While in the service, Sam played for a team from one of the base’s smaller units. He mostly played first base and catcher, only pitching now and then.
He picked up his famous toothpick-chewing habit during Army days. He started with match sticks but switched because they were too expensive and he didn’t like the sulfur tips.
After leaving the Army, Sam played briefly for the Oakland Larks of the West Coast Baseball Association in 1946. That Negro League didn’t last long and folded in its first season under president Abe Saperstein.
In 1947, Quincy Trouppe, manager of the Cleveland Buckeyes, convinced Sam to leave the Army and go pro. Trouppe offered him $550 a month—more than five times his Army pay—and Sam became a full-time pitcher for the Buckeyes.
Negro League Career and Historic Achievements
Sam Jones started his professional baseball journey in the Negro Leagues in 1947 with the Cleveland Buckeyes. Manager Quincy Trouppe really helped him develop as a pitcher.
His time in the Negro Leagues gave him the foundation he’d need to break barriers in Major League Baseball.
Cleveland Buckeyes Tenure
Jones joined the Cleveland Buckeyes of the Negro American League in 1947 after leaving the Army. He switched from playing multiple positions to pitching full-time.
The Buckeyes roster included future major leaguers like Sam Jethroe and Al Smith. Jones posted a 4-2 record in his first season, though some say he might’ve gone 6-3.
The team won the Negro American League championship in 1947 and moved on to face the New York Cubans in the Negro World Series.
Jones made his only World Series appearance in Game Three at Cleveland’s Municipal Stadium. He came into a scoreless tie but gave up six runs in the ninth inning on a mix of hits, walks, and an error.
1948 Season Performance:
- Record: 9-8 (possibly 13-8, depending on the source)
- Team faced financial struggles
- Players rarely saw the promised $550 per month
- Jones usually got only $50-75 monthly
The Buckeyes lost key players Sam Jethroe and Al Smith to major league teams in July 1948. That move signaled the start of the team’s decline.
Influence of Quincy Trouppe
Quincy Trouppe played a huge part in Jones’s growth as a pitcher. The veteran catcher found Jones while managing the Cleveland Buckeyes.
Trouppe recruited Jones out of the Army in 1947, promising him $550 per month—way more than his military pay.
He convinced both Jones and his Army commander to let him make the jump to pro baseball. Trouppe really painted a pretty appealing picture of life in baseball.
Under Trouppe, Jones learned to focus just on pitching. “Quincy was the catcher, and there wasn’t no sense trying to beat out the manager,” Jones said later.
Trouppe’s mentorship didn’t stop with the Buckeyes. When both men reached the majors, they made history together on May 3, 1952, as the first black battery in American League history.
Integration into Professional Baseball
Jones’s Negro League years gave him the tools he’d need for the majors. He learned to harness his powerful, sometimes wild, pitching style during those seasons.
The Cleveland Indians first showed interest in 1948. Still, a scout dismissed Jones with a quick “Won’t do.”
A Cleveland writer suggested Jones work on a better change of pace. At first, he struggled with giving away his off-speed pitches to hitters.
Jones kept working on his craft in winter ball in Panama, playing for the Spur Cola Colonites with teammate Pat Scantlebury.
The Negro Leagues really laid the groundwork for Jones’s eventual success in the majors. His time with the Buckeyes taught him discipline and how to compete at a high level.
By 1951, Jones had sharpened his skills enough to earn a spot with the Cleveland Indians. His Negro League background was crucial as he became the first African American to pitch a no-hitter in Major League Baseball.
Major League Career: Teams and Milestones
Sam Jones pitched for six major league teams over his 14-year career from 1951 to 1964. He became the first African American to throw a no-hitter in the majors and was one of the most dominant strikeout pitchers of his time.
Cleveland Indians Years
Jones broke into the majors with the Cleveland Indians on September 22, 1951. He was 25 when he debuted. The Indians signed him out of the Negro Leagues after he played for the Cleveland Buckeyes.
On May 3, 1952, Jones and catcher Quincy Trouppe made baseball history as the first black battery in American League history. Both had played for the Cleveland Buckeyes before.
Jones spent his first four seasons with Cleveland from 1951 to 1954. He worked on refining his pitching during those years. After the 1954 season, the Indians traded him to the Chicago Cubs for two players to be named later, including slugger Ralph Kiner.
Chicago Cubs Highlights
Jones really hit his stride with the Chicago Cubs from 1955 to 1956. His biggest moment came on May 12, 1955, at Wrigley Field. He threw a no-hitter against the Pittsburgh Pirates, winning 4-0.
The no-hitter was dramatic—he walked three straight batters in the ninth to load the bases, then struck out Dick Groat, Roberto Clemente, and Frank Thomas to seal it.
Jones became the first African American pitcher to throw a no-hitter in Major League Baseball. That was a huge milestone. He made the National League All-Star team in 1955.
During his Cubs stint, Jones led the National League in strikeouts twice, in 1955 and 1956. He also led the league in walks both years, showing off his wild but effective pitching.
St. Louis Cardinals Era
The Cubs traded Jones to the St. Louis Cardinals in 1956 in a multi-player deal. He played for the Cardinals in 1957 and 1958. Jones led the league in strikeouts again in 1958.
His time with the Cardinals showed his consistency as a power pitcher. He built a reputation for having one of the best curveballs in the game. Stan Musial once said, “Sam had the best curveball I ever saw. He was quick and fast and that curve was terrific, so big it was like a change of pace.”
Jones also led the league in walks for the third time in 1958. High strikeouts and high walks really defined his style. Before the 1959 season, the Cardinals traded him to the San Francisco Giants for Bill White and Ray Jablonski.
San Francisco Giants Success
Jones had his best year with the San Francisco Giants in 1959. He led the National League in both wins and ERA. Jones won 21 games, tying with Lew Burdette and Warren Spahn for the league lead.
His 2.83 ERA also topped the National League that year. The Sporting News named him the 1959 National League Pitcher of the Year. He finished second to Early Wynn for the Cy Young Award.
Jones made his second All-Star game in 1959. He pitched for the Giants from 1959 to 1961. With San Francisco, he became one of the Black Aces—African-American pitchers with at least 20 wins in a season.
The expansion Houston Colt .45s picked Jones 25th in the 1961 expansion draft. They traded him to the Detroit Tigers for Bob Bruce and Manny Montejo.
Pitching Style, Strengths, and Nicknames
Sam Jones stood tall on the mound, combining raw power with an intimidating presence. His signature sweeping curveball and fastball made him one of the most feared pitchers of his time. Still, his control issues sometimes drove managers and teammates up the wall.
Signature Curveball and Fastball
Jones’s curveball was legendary. At 6 feet 4 inches and 200 pounds, he used his size to generate a massive sweeping curveball that broke hard across the plate.
He threw his fastball with serious velocity for that era. The combo made him nearly unhittable when he was locked in.
The curveball was his bread and butter. Hitters knew it was coming but still couldn’t square it up. Its sharp break and downward movement fooled even veteran batters from 1951 to 1964.
Power and Control
Jones led the National League in strikeouts three times (1955, 1956, and 1958). His ability to overpower hitters was the stuff of legend.
But his control—or lack of it—was just as well known. He led the league in walks during those same three seasons. That wild, feast-or-famine style made him unpredictable.
Key Statistics:
- Led NL in strikeouts: 1955, 1956, 1958
- Led NL in walks: 1955, 1956, 1958
- Career high: 225 strikeouts in 1959
His wildness actually made him scarier on the mound. Batters never got comfortable, always wondering if Jones would throw a strike or send them diving out of the way.
Origins of ‘Toothpick Sam’ and ‘Sad Sam’
People called Jones “Toothpick Sam” because he always had a toothpick in his mouth while pitching. He started this habit in the Army, where he chewed matchsticks at first, but he switched to toothpicks since matches cost too much.
Jones cared a lot about his toothpicks. He only wanted flat wooden ones, never round. He tried flavored toothpicks, like peppermint and cinnamon, but honestly, he liked plain flat ones best.
The nickname “Sad Sam” stuck because of his mournful face and quiet nature. Jones rarely smiled, and his naturally downcast look reminded folks of another pitcher who had the same nickname years before.
He didn’t talk much—when he did, he kind of mumbled. That serious, almost gloomy expression and his reserved personality made “Sad Sam” the perfect nickname during his career.
Historic No-Hitter and Major Accomplishments
On May 12, 1955, Sam Jones made history as the first African American pitcher to throw a no-hitter in Major League Baseball. He racked up multiple National League strikeout titles and All-Star appearances, cementing his place as one of the era’s most dominant pitchers.
No-Hitter Against the Pittsburgh Pirates
Jones reached baseball immortality on May 12, 1955, at Wrigley Field. Pitching for the Chicago Cubs, he no-hit the Pittsburgh Pirates 4-0 in a game that fans still talk about.
That game had one of the wildest finishes ever. Jones walked the bases loaded in the ninth inning, and suddenly his no-hitter seemed to hang by a thread.
With the crowd holding its breath, Jones struck out the last three batters to save the no-hitter. It was a gutsy, nerve-wracking finish that showed just how tough he was under pressure.
Key Details:
- Date: May 12, 1955
- Venue: Wrigley Field
- Final Score: Cubs 4, Pirates 0
- Strikeouts: Final three batters of the game
This moment broke baseball’s color barrier for no-hitters. Jones did what legends like Satchel Paige might have done sooner if the game had integrated earlier.
NL All-Star Appearances
Jones earned his spot among the National League’s top pitchers with several All-Star selections. His strikeout ability made hitters nervous every time he took the mound.
He brought an intimidating presence to every game. That fastball of his and his drive to compete left a big impression on teammates and opponents alike.
Representing his teams in All-Star games, Jones showed he belonged with baseball’s elite in the 1950s. Those appearances really highlighted just how good he was.
His All-Star nods came during his best years, especially when he led the league in strikeouts. That kind of recognition proved he was among the top power pitchers of his time.
Notable Records and Awards
Jones led the National League in strikeouts three times—1955, 1956, and 1958. He kept that dominance going for several seasons.
His best years lined up with those strikeout titles. The 1955 season stands out, combining his no-hitter with the strikeout crown.
He also led the league in walks three times during those same years. That mix of strikeouts and walks really captured his high-velocity, all-or-nothing style.
Career Highlights:
- First African American to throw MLB no-hitter
- Three-time NL strikeout leader
- Multiple All-Star selections
- 14-year MLB career (1951-1964)
Jones’s records speak to his skill and sheer determination. He fought through plenty of challenges to earn his place in baseball history.
Later Years, Retirement, and Legacy
Sam Jones finished his major league career with the Baltimore Orioles in 1964. After that, he spent his last baseball years as a player-coach in the minors. He helped develop younger pitchers and left a mark as one of the first African-American pitchers to throw a no-hitter.
Final Seasons and International League
Jones wrapped up his big league days with the Baltimore Orioles and Detroit Tigers in 1963 and 1964. For his last four seasons, he played and coached in the minors.
He joined the Columbus Jets of the International League during that stretch. The Jets gave him a chance to keep playing and pass on his experience to up-and-coming players.
Jones stayed in pro baseball until 1967. His career lasted 22 years, starting in 1946 and stretching through the Negro Leagues and several Caribbean countries.
Moving from MLB star to minor league mentor was pretty common for veterans back then. Jones took on the role, even if it meant a step down in competition.
Coaching and Post-Playing Contributions
As a player-coach, Jones worked hands-on with young pitchers. His no-hitter in 1955 gave him real credibility with the next generation.
He shared what he knew about pitching mechanics and the mental side of the game. That intimidating presence and knack for strikeouts became lessons for the rookies.
Coaching let Jones stay part of the game even after his playing days were over. He knew what young pitchers were up against as they tried to move up.
His work in those last years helped connect his playing career to life after baseball.
Influence on Future Generations
Jones made history in 1955 as the first African-American pitcher to throw a no-hitter in the major leagues. That moment really opened doors for Black pitchers who came after him.
He finished his career with a 102-101 record and racked up 1,376 strikeouts. Jones showed everyone that African-American pitchers could absolutely compete at the highest level.
Honestly, he proved that talent didn’t care about racial barriers in baseball. Young pitchers saw what Jones did and realized that determination and skill could actually get them past a lot of obstacles.
His path from the Negro Leagues all the way to major league success inspired a lot of people. It still does.
Samuel Jones passed away in 1971, just four years after he retired from professional baseball. His legacy as a pioneering pitcher and mentor still shapes baseball history.
People felt the impact of his no-hitter and strikeout ability for decades after he left the game.
Experience Baseball History in Person
Want to walk the same grounds where baseball legends made history? Find accommodations near iconic ballparks across America and create your own baseball pilgrimage.
Check availability at hotels near: Yankee Stadium, Fenway Park, Wrigley Field, Dodger Stadium
Plan your ballpark visit: Get MLB Ballpark Tickets and find accommodations nearby.
- Biographies
- Stadium Guides
- Current Baseball Players
- Current Players by Team
- Players that Retired in the 2020s
- Players that Retired in the 2010s
- Players that Retired in the 2000s
- Players that Retired in the 1990s
- Players that Retired in the 1980s
- Players that Retired in the 1970s
- Players that Retired in the 1960s
- Players that Retired in the 1950s
- Players that Retired in the 1940s
- Players that Retired in the 1930s