Yankees’ ALDS Game 3 Comeback vs Blue Jays: 4 Takeaways

The New York Yankees pulled off one of those postseason moments fans talk about for years. Down by five runs, they stormed back to defeat the Toronto Blue Jays in Game 3 of the American League Division Series. Yankee Stadium absolutely shook as 47,399 fans roared. The Yankees’ resilience kept them alive in the series, now trailing 2-1, and suddenly, hopes of a championship felt real again. Aaron Judge capped the comeback with a clutch three-run homer, shutting up the critics and lighting a fire under a team that looked like it might be finished.

Yankees Show Heart in Historic Comeback

By the middle innings, the Yankees were in a bad spot, trailing the Blue Jays 6-1 after a brutal third inning full of defensive mistakes. Toronto took advantage of every slip, including a mental error by Jazz Chisholm Jr. that kept the rally alive and let the Blue Jays tack on four runs. For a while, it felt like the game—and maybe the series—was slipping away.

Aaron Judge Delivers When It Matters Most

With people questioning his postseason play, Aaron Judge came up in the sixth with two on, two strikes, and a whole lot of pressure. He turned on an 0-2 fastball and smashed it off the left-field foul pole, tying the game 6-6. The place went wild. That swing didn’t just erase Toronto’s lead; it reminded everyone why Judge is built for October. He’s got a knack for these moments, doesn’t he?

Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Continues His Bronx Dominance

Even as the Yankees celebrated, one guy just kept haunting them. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. homered for the third straight game at Yankee Stadium. His numbers in the Bronx? Honestly, they’re wild. He’s probably the most dangerous visiting hitter the Yankees have faced at home in years.

Defensive Concerns Still Linger

The Yankees’ defense still raises some eyebrows. Chisholm’s mistake in the third was a reminder—playoff games can swing on mental lapses, not just physical errors. The offense saved them this time, but you have to wonder if these mistakes will come back to bite them.

Pitching Picture for Game 4

The next game feels massive. Toronto now faces a bullpen game after starter Shane Bieber got knocked out early in Game 3, lasting just 2⅔ innings. That’s a lot to ask from their relievers, especially with the stakes this high.

Yankees Rely on Rookie Sensation Cam Schlittler

All eyes in New York are on Cam Schlittler, the rookie who wowed fans by shutting down Boston with eight scoreless innings and 12 strikeouts. Toronto’s lineup is a different beast, though. Schlittler’s going to need all the poise and command he can muster. If he comes close to what he did last time, the Yankees could force a Game 5. That’s a big “if,” but hey, it’s October baseball.

Emergence of Devin Williams as a Bullpen Weapon

Reliever Devin Williams has quietly become one of the Yankees’ best stories this postseason. Fans booed him earlier in the year, but now he’s rattled off 12.1 consecutive scoreless innings, shutting down hitters late in games. His turnaround has given the bullpen a big lift after a shaky September.

Key Takeaways from Game 3

New York’s Game 3 comeback wasn’t just about dodging elimination. It revived confidence in their stars and reminded everyone why postseason baseball in the Bronx feels different.

• Aaron Judge stepped up with some serious clutch plays when it mattered most.
• Even though Guerrero Jr. kept doing damage, the Yankees found ways to answer back at the plate.
• Mental mistakes still pop up, and honestly, they’re going to have to clean those up fast.
• Looking ahead, the pitching matchups for Game 4 might actually give New York an edge—if their rookie starter can handle the heat.
• The bullpen’s looking sharp again, especially with Devin Williams locking things down late.

The series still leans Toronto’s way. The Yankees will need a full team effort to keep their season going.

—

If you want, I can also give this blog post a **search-friendly meta description** for better SEO. Would you like me to add that?

 
Here is the source article for this story: 4 Takeaways From the Yankees’ ALDS Game 3 Win Over the Blue Jays