Yankees Collapse: Are Boone and Cashman to Blame or Players?

The New York Yankees’ 2023 season ended in a way fans know all too well — no championship, again. That’s 16 years and counting without a World Series ring.

Even with their big payroll and legendary status, this latest letdown stirs up tough questions. Is the leadership working? Can the team’s current setup actually deliver?

Joel Sherman’s reflections dig into the players’ mindset, leadership struggles, the futures of Aaron Boone and Brian Cashman, and the big crossroads facing this iconic franchise.

The Harsh Reality of Another Lost Season

The Yankees were built to win. This long drought isn’t just a weird stat — it’s a blow to their whole identity.

They have resources and stars that other teams would love to have. But year after year, they keep falling short, and fans can’t help but wonder: is it time for big changes?

Sherman points out that the pain goes deeper than just losing games. It cuts right into what the Yankees stand for.

The Locker Room Mindset: Stanton Speaks

After the Yankees’ latest exit, Giancarlo Stanton’s postgame comments gave us a peek at the team’s mentality. He didn’t call anyone out, but you could tell he knows some guys aren’t rising to the occasion.

Sherman reads this as a quiet push for more accountability in the clubhouse. Talent’s great, but it’s not enough — the team needs real execution and focus to get it done.

The Accountability Question

Manager Aaron Boone and GM Brian Cashman are catching a lot of heat from frustrated fans. Boone’s game decisions and Cashman’s roster moves have gotten plenty of criticism.

Boone and Cashman: Symptom or Cause?

Sherman questions whether firing Boone or Cashman would really fix things. Sure, they’ve made mistakes, but maybe the bigger issue is the players themselves.

Some of the aging core just hasn’t delivered when it matters most. Swapping out leadership without fixing what’s happening on the field might just be a cosmetic change.

The Aging Core and Narrowing Window

One of the Yankees’ biggest problems is the age and direction of their roster. A lot of key players have passed their prime.

The team doesn’t have enough young, hungry talent to shake things up. Every year that goes by, their window to win gets a little smaller.

The Cost of Standing Still

Sherman warns that doing nothing could lock the Yankees into years of mediocrity. With one of baseball’s highest payrolls, expectations are sky-high.

If they don’t adapt, the heartbreak will keep coming — and the Yankees’ brand as baseball’s powerhouse could start to fade.

Decisions Looming for the Franchise

The front office has a huge offseason ahead. Some of the big questions:

• Leadership assessment – Should Boone and Cashman stay in charge?
• Roster construction – Can they bring in younger, more flexible players?
• Accountability culture – How do they build a team that shows up in October, not just April through September?
• Strategic vision – Are they willing to take short-term hits for long-term success?

Balancing Tradition with Evolution

Change isn’t easy for a team so steeped in history. But tradition doesn’t mean much if the trophies stop coming.

The Yankees need to find a way to mix their classic appeal with modern strategies, sharper analytics, and a clubhouse culture that fits today’s game. That’s a tall order — but what else would you expect from a team like this?

The Road Ahead

Sherman’s reflections make it clear: the Yankees stand at a crossroads. They can stick with the status quo and hope things just click, or they might need to take some gutsy, maybe even unpopular, swings to reset the team’s direction.

The decision will shape whether this championship drought fades into history or winds up defining a new, less glorious era for the franchise.

Fans are restless. Players feel the pressure, and leadership faces tough questions. This offseason? It’s shaping up to deliver drama, hard choices, and a real look at just how much the Yankees value their winning tradition.

—
 
Here is the source article for this story: Joel Sherman’s 3 Things I Think: Are Boone and Cashman to blame, or…