Best MLB Free-Agent Starting Pitchers 2025-26: Rankings

The upcoming 2025–26 MLB free-agent class for starting pitchers doesn’t really have that one, obvious, dominant ace sitting at the top. Still, there’s a seriously deep pool of arms that could shake up any rotation in a hurry.

We’re talking proven postseason performers, a few intriguing international imports, and a mix of experience and upside. Whether a team’s chasing a durable innings-eater, a wild strikeout artist, or just a crafty veteran who’s been there in October, this market’s about to get noisy.

Let’s take a look at the most interesting names and storylines that’ll drive the winter bidding wars.

The Top of the Market: Proven Performers

This class might not have a household name that everyone fears, but it’s got arms that can anchor a staff. Framber Valdez leads the way—since 2020, he’s been one of the most reliable pitchers in the game.

Valdez mixes durability, a knack for getting ground balls, and a calmness that doesn’t really crack under pressure. He’s not flashy, but he’s a safe, valuable investment for any contender.

High-Upside Threats

Right behind Valdez, there’s Dylan Cease. He’s got that electric stuff, but man, his track record is a rollercoaster.

Some years he looks like a Cy Young candidate, and other seasons he’s just… not. Teams will have to decide if his upside is worth the risk of inconsistency.

Pitchers Thriving on Command Over Power

Not every top arm in this group relies on pure velocity. Some guys just keep hitters guessing and off-balance.

Ranger Suárez fits that mold perfectly. He lives on pinpoint command and soft contact, not strikeouts, but his style leads to efficient outings and low pitch counts—something managers absolutely love in tight playoff races.

International Intrigue: Tatsuya Imai

No. 4 is Japan’s Tatsuya Imai, a right-hander from NPB stepping into the MLB free-agent spotlight for the first time. Imai’s put up strong numbers overseas and seems adaptable enough to take on North American hitters.

Scouts and front offices are definitely curious to see how his stuff translates.

Promising, Yet Risky Investments

Michael King lands at No. 5 after some eye-catching performances, though injuries have often limited his workload. Some teams might worry about that, but if you’re willing to gamble, the upside could be huge.

Zac Gallen once looked like a future perennial All-Star, but recent struggles dropped him to No. 6. Still, his track record suggests there’s a bounce-back in there, and a team with faith in his edge could get a bargain.

Veteran Reliability

Merrill Kelly and Chris Bassitt don’t light up radar guns anymore, but at 37, they bring loads of experience to any clubhouse. Their smarts, ability to adjust, and history of success make them pretty appealing for teams looking for short-term deals that won’t blow up in their faces.

The Ageless Wonder and Other Notables

At 43, Justin Verlander just keeps going—his strong second half for the Giants turned some heads. His fire, leadership, and knack for big moments could tempt contenders who need a steady, veteran arm for a playoff push.

Rounding Out the Top Ten

Tyler Mahle rounds off the list. He’s got clear talent, but injuries keep popping up. If he can stay healthy, he offers solid mid-rotation value with a bit of upside.

Honorable Mentions

Other arms to keep an eye on:

• Max Scherzer – Hall of Fame résumé and that legendary competitive streak
• Zach Eflin – Steady, solid mid-rotation presence
• Cody Ponce – Reliable depth piece
• Lucas Giolito – Can pitch like a frontline starter when he’s on
• Nick Martinez – Versatile, can start or relieve
• Zack Littell – Recent strong outings in spot starts
• Kona Takahashi – Another NPB pitcher who could make things interesting

Final Thoughts

The 2025–26 MLB free-agent starting pitcher class offers a fascinating mix of depth and variety. There may not be a single, generational ace, but the storylines and talent run deep.

Front offices and scouting departments are probably already buzzing. Fans can expect plenty of drama and some crafty maneuvering.

Maybe Valdez keeps rolling, or maybe Imai surprises everyone with an international leap. No matter what, pitching-needy teams will find something to chase.

—

If you want, I can also provide **meta description, alt tags, and SEO keyword suggestions** to fully optimize this blog post for search rankings. Would you like me to add those too?
 
Here is the source article for this story: Who are the best free-agent starting pitchers? We ranked them