Rockies First Base Targets: Realistic Free-Agent Options

The Colorado Rockies have a big decision looming as the 2026 season gets closer. First base stands out as the team’s most urgent question mark.

With pitchers and catchers reporting in about six weeks, the front office faces a tough call. Should they stick with internal options, chase free agents, or try to juggle cost, leadership, and upside?

Paul DePodesta has led the Rockies to value organizational depth over headline-grabbing signings so far. But first base might finally push them to act differently.

First Base: The Rockies’ Biggest Roster Question

Blaine Crim heads into the offseason as the likely starting first baseman. He’s familiar and affordable, but the Rockies aren’t pretending the job is locked up.

Troy Johnston, picked up on waivers, is in the mix. The front office hasn’t ruled out bringing in someone from outside, either.

DePodesta has said players and agents are reaching out, even if Colorado hasn’t made many formal offers yet. That hints the quiet part of the offseason might be ending, especially when it comes to first base.

Why First Base Matters More Than Usual

The lineup leans right-handed, and injuries to young core guys like Ezequiel Tovar make stability a real need. First base isn’t just about filling a spot—it’s about leadership and taking pressure off the team’s younger hitters.

Veteran Stability vs. Offensive Upside

The Rockies have plenty of options in free agency and trades, each with their own upsides and drawbacks. There are veterans nearing retirement and productive bats who won’t come cheap.

Cost control has been the theme for this front office, but maybe first base is the spot to spend a little for some reliability and leadership in a young clubhouse.

Carlos Santana: Low Risk, High IQ

Carlos Santana is now 40, but he brings more than just a bat. His 2025 numbers dipped (.219/.308/.325), but he still shows elite discipline and defense.

• 32 Defensive Runs Saved over the last three seasons
• 2024 Gold Glove winner

Santana looks like a short-term, low-risk choice. His leadership could matter as much as his stats.

Nathaniel Lowe: Costly but Consistent

Nathaniel Lowe might be the most intriguing option out there. He’s a lefty with steady power—18 homers in 2025—and he won a 2023 Gold Glove.

But his Super Two arbitration status could make him pricey, maybe even too pricey. The Rockies have to decide if the production is worth the cost.

Bounce-Back Bets and Budget Plays

If Colorado wants value, a few names jump out. These players might not guarantee a star, but they won’t break the bank either.

Rhys Hoskins and Justin Turner: Familiar Faces

Rhys Hoskins is coming back from ACL surgery and still has power—26 homers in 2024—but his defense and overall production have slipped. Milwaukee declined his $18 million option, so he might be a bargain now.

Justin Turner, now 41, could steady the clubhouse and fill in at first or DH. He’d probably cost around $6 million and would bring instant credibility.

Dominic Smith: Quietly Interesting

Dominic Smith could be the cheapest choice. He’s a lefty who hit .284/.333/.417 in 63 games for San Francisco last year, and you could probably sign him for under $3 million.

As a platoon bat, Smith gives you some sneaky value without a big commitment. Not flashy, but maybe that’s just what Colorado needs right now.

The Decision That Shapes 2026

The Rockies have plenty of options. Each one comes with its own philosophy.

First base is where we’ll see how aggressive the front office wants to be in 2026. Are they ready to spend, or will they play it safe?

Maybe Colorado goes with steady veterans. Maybe they try a budget-friendly platoon.

Or maybe they chase a bigger bat for more impact. After a winter that’s felt a bit too patient, first base could finally be where things get interesting.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Wednesday Rockpile: Who could the Rockies realistically sign to play first base?