Blue Jays Won’t Blame Kiner-Falefa for Game 7 Loss

The Toronto Blue Jays’ crushing Game 7 loss in the World Series will stick in memory for one play: Isiah Kiner-Falefa getting called out at the plate on what might have been the championship-winning run.

Afterward, manager John Schneider went out of his way to defend his player and staff. He broke down the decision-making, the strategy behind Kiner-Falefa’s short lead, and why no one person should carry the weight of how the Series ended.

Breaking Down the Controversial Final Play

It was the ninth inning of Game 7. The score was tied, the season on the line, and Kiner-Falefa stood at third as the potential winning run.

The Blue Jays were just a clean slide away from a title. Instead, the moment became one of the most dissected plays of the postseason.

The Short Lead That Changed Everything

Schneider insists Kiner-Falefa’s lead at third wasn’t a mistake. It was a deliberate call.

Third base coach Carlos Febles advised the pinch runner to take what turned out to be an unusually short lead—one of the shortest ever seen in World Series play.

The logic? Minimize the risk of a back-pick. Dodgers catcher Will Smith has a reputation for aggressively picking off runners at third, especially with a lefty hitter at the plate.

So the Jays played it safe, choosing to stay close to the bag and avoid disaster instead of trying to get the biggest jump home.

But that choice directly affected what happened next. When the ball went into play, Kiner-Falefa had less ground covered than most runners in that spot.

What could have been a comfortable score turned into a play at the plate decided by inches.

The Slow Roller, the Stumble, and the Throw

The ball itself didn’t look like a “series-defining moment.” It was a slow two-hopper to Dodgers second baseman Miguel Rojas—usually the sort of contact that favors the offense with the infield in and the bases loaded.

Rojas even stumbled as he charged the ball. That brief slip might have cracked the door for a Jays walk-off.

But he recovered and made a strong, accurate throw to the plate. That quick recovery, paired with Kiner-Falefa’s short lead, turned a high-percentage scoring chance into a photo finish.

Why Schneider Refuses to Blame Kiner-Falefa

After the game and in the days since, Schneider hasn’t wavered: Kiner-Falefa isn’t the scapegoat.

The manager stressed that Kiner-Falefa did exactly what he was asked. He handled the play the way the coaching staff drew it up.

Evaluating the Slide and the Alternatives

Schneider said Kiner-Falefa’s slide was well-executed. He went in cleanly, on line, and gave the Jays every shot to get called safe.

Umpire Jordan Baker called him out, and after a tense video review, the call stood.

Could anything have been done differently? Schneider tackled that head-on:

From his view, the runner did his job. The defense, the short lead, and the on-target throw all combined to deny Toronto the title.

The Defensive Pressure and Context

It’s easy to overlook just how tough the defense had it. The Dodgers brought the infield in, dead set on cutting off the run at home.

The bases were loaded, the stadium tense, and a season’s pressure hung over every move. The Jays’ strategy respected Smith’s back-pick threat but still trusted a routine grounder would get the run home.

The outcome was brutal, but the thinking behind it made sense.

A Season of Highs, Lows, and Unpredictable Recognition

Looking back, Schneider actually managed to find a bit of humor in it all. He joked about finishing second in AL Manager of the Year voting—just another example of how little you can predict when it comes to awards in baseball.

Game 7 felt like chaos in slow motion. A slow roller. A stumble. Someone took a short lead, and then came a perfect throw—tiny moments that decided the whole championship.

For the Blue Jays, and especially Isiah Kiner-Falefa, the line between glory and heartbreak was razor-thin. It’s wild how baseball can do that, isn’t it?

 
Here is the source article for this story: Jays won’t blame Kiner-Falefa for Game 7 loss