Guardians Need More Bats to Sustain World Series Run

The Cleveland Guardians pulled off one of baseball’s wildest comebacks in 2025, clawing back from a massive 15.5-game hole to swipe the AL Central. Still, behind that surge, there’s a blunt truth: this offense hit a franchise-worst .226 and just isn’t set up, as things stand, to win a World Series in 2026.

This piece digs into why Cleveland needs to move on from their pitching-first blueprint and finally add one or two proven bats. At this point, it’s not just a nice-to-have—it’s a must.

The 2025 Guardians: Incredible Comeback, Deep Flaws

2025 will be remembered in Cleveland, no doubt. A young roster, a gritty clubhouse, and a lights-out pitching staff dragged the Guardians from the edge of irrelevance to a division title.

But the numbers don’t lie. A team batting average of .226 isn’t just a cold stretch—it’s a red flag. For a club that usually hangs its hat on contact and situational hitting, finishing with the lowest average in team history really puts their whole run in perspective.

Why the Comeback Masks Offensive Issues

Comebacks can fool you. They look like growth, but sometimes they just cover up bigger issues. The Guardians squeezed every last run out of a streaky lineup and leaned on their pitching to stay alive.

That formula can work over a long season in a weak division. But come October, it usually falls apart against elite pitching.

A Young Core That Hasn’t Fully Arrived

Cleveland’s front office deserves credit for stacking up young position players. On paper, the core looks like what you want: athletic, versatile, affordable.

But let’s be real—they’re still more about potential than production. Several guys have bounced between Triple-A and the bigs, never quite locking in as everyday threats. That forces the staff to keep shuffling the lineup, and it’s obvious when the offense goes quiet for stretches.

The Double-Edged Sword of Versatility

Guys like Jose Ramirez and Steven Kwan give Cleveland some real flexibility. They can move around the field and fit into different lineup spots, which helps cover injuries and mix things up.

But sometimes, all that moving around just leads to more shuffling instead of letting young hitters settle in. Constant role changes and spotty at-bats can mess with a player’s growth, especially when they’re still finding their footing.

Why the Guardians Need Proven Bats Now

The Guardians don’t need to blow up the offense, but they do need anchors. One or two established hitters—ideally right-handed—could stabilize the lineup, deepen the order, and let the young guys breathe a bit.

This isn’t about blocking prospects. It’s about surrounding them with pros who’ve been there before. Cleveland can’t shop for the biggest names, but the middle of the market is where smart teams find value.

Mid-Tier Targets Who Make Sense

The specific names might shift as the offseason unfolds, but these are the types Cleveland should chase:

None of these guys are superstars now, but each could give the offense the lift it needs. Sometimes, that’s the difference between being on the fringe and really threatening in October.

Payroll Reality and Roster Construction

The Guardians’ finances are tight, but not a lost cause. With about $40 million tied up in seven players for 2026, there’s some room to make moves—just not enough to chase the biggest fish.

The front office has to get it right. Every dollar matters here, and spending on bats means there’s less wiggle room elsewhere.

From Pitching-First to Balanced Contender

Cleveland’s poured resources into pitching for years—draft picks, development, payroll. It’s worked, giving them one of the deepest staffs in the league. But there comes a point where another arm doesn’t help as much as a couple of real hitters.

This winter, it’s all about finding balance. The Guardians’ path forward probably looks like this:

The Risk of Standing Still

Cleveland’s pitching and prospect pipeline give them a high floor. They’re unlikely to collapse, which is something, but “solid” just doesn’t cut it anymore—not after a 15.5-game comeback and a division title.

The window is starting to open. And let’s be honest, windows in small markets don’t stay open for long.

If Cleveland doesn’t make real offensive upgrades, they’ll probably get stuck in the same old loop: good enough to chase the AL Central, but not nearly dangerous enough when the postseason gets real. If 2025 is supposed to be more than a one-hit wonder, this offseason needs to be when they finally invest in offense and put together a lineup that actually matches their pitching staff.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Guardians need more bats to continue pursuit of World Series victory