Jerry Lumpe made his mark with a solid 12-year career in Major League Baseball, playing from 1956 to 1967 as a versatile infielder for three teams.
He grew up in Lincoln, Missouri, born in 1933, and started his pro journey with the New York Yankees. But he really found his stride as a starting second baseman with the Kansas City Athletics and Detroit Tigers.
Lumpe walked away from baseball after the 1967 season. He played his last game on October 1, 1967, in a tense pennant race for the Detroit Tigers against the California Angels.
His career covered an era of big changes in baseball, from the Yankees’ dynasty in the late ’50s to the competitive American League races of the mid-’60s.
Lumpe showed impressive consistency and defensive reliability, while also chipping in meaningful offense. He started out as a Yankees utility player and became an All-Star second baseman, which says a lot about his persistence and adaptability.
Jerry Lumpe’s Baseball Career Overview
Jerry Lumpe played 12 seasons in Major League Baseball from 1956 to 1967. He built a reputation as a reliable infielder for three different teams.
He started as a utility player with the Yankees, then became a starting second baseman with the Kansas City Athletics. He finished up his career with the Detroit Tigers.
Career Timeline and Teams
Jerry Lumpe kicked off his MLB career with the New York Yankees in 1956 at age 22. He spent four seasons (1956-1959) with the Yankees, mostly as a utility infielder.
During his Yankees years, Lumpe played in two World Series. In the 1957 World Series against the Milwaukee Braves, he started three games at third base.
The very next year, he picked up a World Series championship ring when the Yankees beat the Braves in 1958.
In May 1959, the Yankees traded Lumpe to the Kansas City Athletics. That trade really changed the course of his career.
He spent five seasons (1959-1963) with Kansas City and became their regular starting second baseman.
His best years came with the Athletics. In 1962, Lumpe hit .301 with 193 hits, finishing second in the American League in hits and triples.
The Detroit Tigers brought Lumpe on board in November 1963. He played his last four seasons (1964-1967) in Detroit and made the 1964 American League All-Star team.
Position Versatility and Roles
Lumpe showed real versatility throughout his career, playing three different infield spots well. He came into the Yankees system as a shortstop (SS) but adapted to different roles as needed.
With the Yankees, he mostly played third base (3B), starting 54 games there. His World Series games all came at third base.
Kansas City turned him into a second baseman (2B), and that’s where he shined the most. In 1960, his first full year at second, he played 127 games there and led the team with 156 hits.
He always brought solid defensive skills, no matter the position. In 1963, he posted a .988 fielding percentage at second base, almost leading the American League. Across all infield positions, he kept a career .980 fielding percentage.
In Detroit, Lumpe stayed their main second baseman through 1966. In 1964, he started 156 games at second base, tying Bobby Knoop for most starts among AL second basemen.
Notable Trades and Transfers
Three big trades shaped Lumpe’s career. On May 26, 1959, the Yankees sent him to Kansas City with pitchers Johnny Kucks and Tom Sturdivant for outfielder Héctor López and pitcher Ralph Terry.
That trade got Lumpe out of his utility role. He was batting just .222 with the Yankees, but Kansas City made him their starting second baseman right away.
The next big trade came on November 18, 1963. Kansas City traded Lumpe, Dave Wickersham, and Ed Rakow to Detroit for Rocky Colavito, Bob Anderson, and $50,000. The Athletics were clearing space for young second baseman Dick Green.
Detroit gave Lumpe another shot as a starter. He played second base alongside shortstop Dick McAuliffe in the Tigers’ infield.
By his last season in 1967, Lumpe saw less playing time as McAuliffe slid over to second base. Lumpe played in 81 games and started his final one on October 1, 1967, in a doubleheader against the California Angels.
Major League Teams and Highlights
Jerry Lumpe spent 12 seasons on three major league teams. He won a World Series with the Yankees in 1958 and made the All-Star team with the Tigers in 1964.
His best years were with the Kansas City Athletics, where he became a steady second baseman and offensive contributor.
New York Yankees Era
Lumpe started his MLB career with the New York Yankees in 1956 after scout Tom Greenwade signed him. He debuted on April 17, 1956, at age 22.
From 1956-1959, Lumpe mostly played as a utility infielder for the Yankees. He got into both the 1957 World Series and 1958 World Series as the starting third baseman.
In 1957, he played three World Series games against the Milwaukee Braves. He picked up four hits in 14 at-bats, but the Yankees lost in seven games.
The next year, things went better. Lumpe got his World Series championship ring in 1958 when the Yankees beat the Braves in a rematch. He started three games, including the big Game 7 win.
Even with his postseason contributions, Lumpe struggled to lock down a regular starting spot. He was hitting just .222 in 18 games when the Yankees traded him to Kansas City on May 26, 1959.
Kansas City Athletics Prime
The Kansas City Athletics trade really turned things around for Lumpe. He became their starting second baseman and had his best seasons from 1960-1963.
In 1960, Lumpe played 127 games at second and hit .271 with 156 hits. His .982 fielding percentage ranked third among American League second basemen.
He hit his offensive stride in 1961 and 1962. In 1961, he batted .293 with 167 hits and nine triples, finishing second in the AL in triples.
The 1962 season was his best. Lumpe hit .301 with 193 hits, finishing second in the league in hits and triples (10). He drove in 83 runs and scored 89 times, all while keeping a .980 fielding percentage.
His strong 1962 earned him 25th place in AL MVP voting. The Athletics leaned heavily on Lumpe’s reliability during those years.
Detroit Tigers Contributions
The Detroit Tigers picked up Lumpe in November 1963 in a trade that sent Rocky Colavito to Kansas City. Lumpe became Detroit’s starting second baseman for the 1964 season.
He started 156 games at second in 1964, tying Bobby Knoop for most starts among AL second basemen. His defensive skills stayed sharp, ranking in the top five among AL second basemen in putouts, assists, and double plays.
That year, he got his only All-Star selection. Lumpe was picked as a reserve behind Bobby Richardson for the July 7 game at Shea Stadium, but he didn’t get into the game.
He remained a regular for the Tigers through 1966, though his bat cooled off. In 1967, as Detroit battled in a four-team pennant race, Lumpe saw his role shrink when Dick McAuliffe moved to second base.
Lumpe played his last game on October 1, 1967, in a doubleheader against the California Angels. The Tigers needed wins to tie for the pennant but lost both, ending their championship hopes and Lumpe’s career.
Career Achievements and Recognition
Jerry Lumpe earned respect for his consistent play and reliability during his 12-season career. His biggest personal achievement was an All-Star selection in 1964, and he contributed to two World Series titles with the Yankees.
All-Star Selection
Lumpe got his only All-Star nod in 1964 while playing for the Detroit Tigers. That came during a solid season where he kept up steady offensive production at second base.
That All-Star selection was the high point of his individual recognition. His pick showed how much people valued him as a dependable middle infielder who could help both on defense and offense.
He only made one All-Star team, but Lumpe’s steady performance throughout his career earned respect from teammates and opponents. That 1964 nod really validated his place among the American League’s reliable second basemen in that era.
World Series Appearances
Lumpe played in two World Series with the Yankees in 1957 and 1958. Both appearances ended with championship victories for the Yankees.
In the 1957 World Series, Lumpe appeared in six games and hit .286 with four hits in 14 at-bats. He drove in two RBIs as the Yankees went seven games against the Milwaukee Braves.
The next year in 1958, Lumpe again played in six World Series games. He batted .167 with two hits in 12 at-bats against the Braves.
These World Series appearances came early in Lumpe’s career, while he was still trying to establish himself as a regular. Those championships gave him the highest team achievement of his career.
MVP Voting and Awards
Lumpe had his best statistical season in 1962 with the Kansas City Athletics, finishing 25th in American League MVP voting. That year, he hit .301, racked up 193 hits, and drove in 83 RBIs.
His 1962 season really stood out. Lumpe’s 193 hits and .301 average showed he could get on base and drive in runs consistently.
The MVP recognition, though not a top finish, acknowledged Lumpe’s value during his best year. His performance made him a key piece of the Athletics’ lineup during his Kansas City run.
Lumpe’s career WAR of 15.4 shows his overall contribution to his teams over those 12 seasons.
Offensive Performance and Batting Statistics
Jerry Lumpe finished with a career .268 batting average, 1,314 hits, 47 home runs, and 454 RBIs over 12 seasons from 1956-1967.
His best offensive numbers came with the Kansas City Athletics, where he hit .279 with 775 hits and 277 RBIs in five seasons.
Runs and RBIs
Lumpe scored 620 runs during his career, averaging 73 runs per 162 games. His best year for runs came in 1962, when he crossed the plate 89 times for Kansas City.
That same year, he drove in a career-high 83 RBIs, which got him some MVP votes.
As a second baseman, he regularly chipped in to his team’s offense. He had 50 or more RBIs in six seasons.
His run production peaked while with Kansas City from 1959-1963, averaging 72 runs per year.
Lumpe’s knack for getting on base and driving in runs made him a steady offensive contributor. He tallied 54 RBIs in both 1961 and 1962 for the Athletics.
Most of his 454 career RBIs came from setting the table rather than hitting for power, which fits his role as a table-setter.
Home Runs and Power Numbers
Power just wasn’t Lumpe’s thing, honestly—you can see that in his 47 career home runs. He hit a career-high 10 homers in 1962, but never got past eight in any other season.
He finished with a .356 slugging percentage, showing his preference for gap-to-gap hitting. Most of his 1,749 total bases came from singles and doubles.
Over 12 years, Lumpe collected 190 doubles and 52 triples. The lefty hitter put up his best power stats while playing for Kansas City.
In those five years with the Athletics, he hit 29 home runs and slugged .377. When he went to Detroit, his power dropped off—a mere 15 home runs in four seasons.
Batting Average and OBP
Lumpe finished with a .268 career batting average, which fits the mold of a contact hitter. His top season came in 1962, when he hit .301 for Kansas City.
He also managed a .293 average in 1961 and hit .340 in limited chances with the Yankees back in 1957. His on-base percentage of .325 hints at his knack for drawing walks and getting on base.
Lumpe drew 428 walks and struck out 411 times. That kind of patience made him a solid choice for the leadoff or second spot in the lineup.
He hit .279 during his Kansas City years, compared to .248 with Detroit. His plate discipline stayed steady, and his .681 OPS ranked 87th among league average for his era.
Season-by-Season Review
Lumpe really broke out in 1962, posting career highs in batting average (.301), RBIs (83), and home runs (10). He played 156 games that year and racked up 700 plate appearances.
He followed up with a .293 average and 167 hits in 1961. Those two seasons marked the high point of his offensive game.
Things got tough during his last years in Detroit. His average dipped to .231 in 1966, and he managed just .232 in his final season in 1967.
Despite slumping numbers, Lumpe kept his reputation as a steady contact hitter who almost never struck out.
Fielding and Defensive Value
Jerry Lumpe built a name for himself as a reliable defender all over the infield during his 12 years in the majors. He mainly played second base, where he showed off solid fundamentals and consistency.
Second Base Defensive Skills
Lumpe became known as a dependable second baseman. He played with steady hands and always seemed to be in the right spot.
At 6-foot-2, he had great reach around the bag. The Kansas City Athletics leaned on Lumpe’s defensive consistency from 1960 to 1963.
He turned double plays well and covered ground up the middle. With his left-handed batting stance, he saw the ball well coming from pitchers.
Lumpe’s defense at 2B proved especially valuable in Detroit. The Tigers counted on his experience to steady their infield.
He rarely made costly errors and always seemed to be in the right position for each hitter. His throws from second stayed accurate year after year.
Lumpe understood base-running tendencies and had a good sense of timing on stolen base attempts.
Shortstop and Third Base Abilities
In his early Yankees days, Lumpe played both shortstop and third base. That versatility made him a handy utility infielder.
Playing SS let him show off his arm strength on those long throws. At third base, he handled hot corner duties when needed.
His quick reflexes helped him snag hard-hit balls down the line. He covered ground to both sides decently.
The 3B position demanded quick reactions, which Lumpe picked up over time. His height made it easier to field high choppers and line drives.
He could make the long throw to first base accurately. This flexibility kept his career going and made him more valuable to his teams.
Managers liked having a guy who could handle multiple infield positions without missing a beat.
Fielding Statistics
Lumpe’s defensive stats backed up his steady approach to fielding. He kept fielding percentages consistent across his career, no matter the position.
His error totals stayed low for someone who played as much as he did.
Career Defensive Breakdown:
- Primary Position: Second Base
- Secondary Positions: Shortstop, Third Base
- Playing Style: Steady, reliable defender
- Key Strength: Positional versatility
The numbers paint Lumpe as more of a fundamentally sound defender than a flashy one. He made the routine plays and avoided big mistakes.
Teams liked that he could fill in when injuries happened. Lumpe’s fielding helped him stay in the lineup year after year.
Retirement, Legacy, and Post-Career Life
Jerry Lumpe wrapped up his 12-year major league run on October 1, 1967, playing his final game for Detroit in a tense pennant race doubleheader. After retiring, Lumpe moved into coaching, then later tried his hand at banking and insurance.
Final Season and Transition
In 1967, Lumpe’s playing time really dropped off. He got into just 81 games, hit .232, and started only 31 times at second base.
Dick McAuliffe shifted from shortstop to become Detroit’s main second baseman, which pushed Lumpe into a backup role during a wild pennant chase.
That four-team American League race included the Tigers, White Sox, Twins, and Red Sox. Lumpe started the last game of the season—second game of a doubleheader—against the California Angels.
Detroit needed a win to force a tie for the pennant with Boston. Lumpe singled in his only at-bat, then Dick Tracewski took over in the third inning.
The Tigers ended up losing 8-5, which handed the championship to the Red Sox. Nineteen days later, Detroit released Lumpe and his playing career was over.
Legacy and Impact on Baseball
Lumpe’s 12-year stats show steady, reliable play across three teams. He appeared in 1,371 games, hit .268, and collected 47 home runs with 454 RBIs.
His best years came with the Kansas City Athletics from 1960 to 1963. In 1962, he batted .301 with 193 hits, finishing second in the league in both hits and triples.
He earned his only All-Star nod in 1964 as a backup to Bobby Richardson. Lumpe posted a strong .980 fielding percentage in his career, mostly at second base.
Career Highlights:
- World Series champion (1958)
- All-Star selection (1964)
- Two World Series appearances (1957, 1958)
- Missouri Sports Hall of Fame inductee (1994)
He could play second base, third base, and shortstop without missing a beat. That kind of flexibility made him a real asset to every team he played for.
Later Years and Passing
After he retired, Lumpe spent a season as the first base coach for the Oakland Athletics in 1971. He worked with manager Dick Williams, who had been both his Kansas City teammate and the manager of the 1967 Red Sox.
The 1971 Athletics racked up 101 wins and grabbed the American League West Division title. Still, they couldn’t get past the Baltimore Orioles in the ALCS and lost all three games.
When his coaching run ended, Lumpe left baseball for good. He tried his hand at banking and insurance, building a life in Springfield, Missouri’s business scene.
Lumpe kept close ties with Missouri State University. He’d won two NAIA basketball championships there back in 1952 and 1953.
He stayed in Springfield for the rest of his life. In 1994, the Missouri Sports Hall of Fame inducted Lumpe, honoring everything he’d done for sports in the state.
Jerry Lumpe passed away from cancer on August 15, 2014, at 81, in Springfield. His wife of 60 years, Vivian, survived him, along with their children and grandchildren.
Experience Baseball History in Person
Want to walk the same grounds where baseball legends made history? Find accommodations near iconic ballparks across America and create your own baseball pilgrimage.
Check availability at hotels near: Yankee Stadium, Fenway Park, Wrigley Field, Dodger Stadium
Plan your ballpark visit: Get MLB Ballpark Tickets and find accommodations nearby.
- Biographies
- Stadium Guides
- Current Baseball Players
- Current Players by Team
- Players that Retired in the 2020s
- Players that Retired in the 2010s
- Players that Retired in the 2000s
- Players that Retired in the 1990s
- Players that Retired in the 1980s
- Players that Retired in the 1970s
- Players that Retired in the 1960s
- Players that Retired in the 1950s
- Players that Retired in the 1940s
- Players that Retired in the 1930s