Pete Alonso Agrees to Five-Year Deal with Orioles

The Baltimore Orioles are on the verge of making the boldest move of the Mike Elias era. They’re reportedly finalizing a five-year, $155 million deal with New York Mets slugger Pete Alonso.

Pending a physical, this deal would reshape Baltimore’s lineup right away. It could even redefine the franchise’s financial identity and competitive ceiling for the next five years.

Orioles Land the Middle-of-the-Order Bat They’ve Been Chasing

For two winters now, the Orioles have chased big bats but usually stopped short of paying top dollar. This time, though, they didn’t hesitate.

Alonso’s reported five-year, $155 million contract sets a record average annual value for a first baseman on a deal this length. Baltimore’s sending a loud message—they’re serious about contending deep into October.

The agreement comes after the club missed out on Kyle Schwarber. They’d offered him a similar proposal.

If Schwarber was Plan A, the Orioles pivoted fast and landed a player whose skill set might fit Camden Yards even better.

Contract Structure: No Deferrals, No Opt-Outs, Limited No-Trade

The Orioles went with a clean, straightforward contract. Alonso’s deal reportedly includes:

For Baltimore, no deferrals mean the net present value is higher. It’s the most substantial deal in franchise history.

For Alonso, it’s a firm commitment in both term and structure—a reward for betting on himself after turning down a Mets extension.

Alonso’s Path from Mets Mainstay to Orioles Cornerstone

Alonso’s road to this moment wasn’t exactly smooth. In 2023, he rejected a seven-year, $158 million extension from the Mets and chose to ride out arbitration and short-term deals.

New York responded by signing him to a two-year, $54 million contract covering 2024–25. It looked risky when Alonso struggled in 2024, and some critics wondered if his power-first profile was slipping.

A 2025 Rebound That Re-Established His Market

Those worries faded quick. Alonso bounced back with a strong 2025, putting himself back among the game’s top right-handed power threats. Here’s his final line:

The improved underlying data—exit velocity, hard-hit rate, and pull power—turned a lot of heads. Teams believed 2024 was just a blip, not a trend, and that pushed his market past what the Mets wanted to pay.

Mets’ Cautious Approach Opens the Door

From New York’s side, this one’s gotta sting. Alonso’s been a franchise face, but the Mets reportedly wouldn’t go past three guaranteed years and never matched what other teams offered.

That opened the door, and the Orioles jumped. For Mets fans, seeing Alonso leave after years of production and loyalty just adds to the frustration.

New York’s Loss, Baltimore’s Gain

Baltimore’s making the kind of move contenders do when their window is wide open. Alonso brings instant credibility and a postseason-ready profile to a club with a strong young core.

His presence in the middle of the lineup should stabilize the offense through the 162-game grind and into October.

How Alonso Fits into an Emerging Power Lineup

Alonso isn’t showing up alone to a once contact-heavy Orioles offense. Earlier this winter, Baltimore traded for outfielder Taylor Ward, another proven power bat who deepens the middle of the order.

Together, Alonso and Ward reshape the lineup. Instead of relying only on homegrown bats to take the next step, the Orioles now have established sluggers who’ve already proven they can handle big-stage pitching.

Trade Flexibility: Prospects as Pitching Currency

The Alonso deal has another effect—it changes how the Orioles can use their talent surplus. With first base locked down and the lineup more set, the front office can shop young hitters for pitching help.

Names most often mentioned include:

Those players could headline packages to address rotation or bullpen needs. Elias and his staff have said they want to upgrade on the mound; with Alonso in place, the idea of who’s untouchable might shift.

Financial Impact and Long-Term Outlook in Baltimore

Alonso’s $31 million annual salary is a landmark for a franchise known for cautious spending. But in the context of the Orioles’ current payroll, it’s more aggressive pivot than reckless gamble.

Baltimore enters this commitment with few long-term obligations beyond 2026. That gives them both short-term punch and medium-term flexibility.

Even with Alonso’s deal, they’ve still got room to add pitching or extend key young players—if they want to go that route.

A Defining Move for the Mike Elias Era

By net present value, this is the largest contract in Orioles history. It’s a clear stake in the ground for Elias.

Honestly, it signals that the rebuild phase is over. This is the contention phase now, and elite talent will get paid accordingly.

If Alonso lives up to what his rebound season and those underlying metrics suggest, this contract could be remembered as the turning point. Maybe this is what finally pushes Baltimore from “up-and-coming” to a real, sustained contender.

The next moves—especially in the rotation and bullpen—will decide just how far this new-look Orioles club can go. Feels like a lot is riding on what comes next, doesn’t it?

 
Here is the source article for this story: Orioles, Pete Alonso Agree To Five-Year Deal