Top MLB Managers of 2025: Players’ Preferences Revealed

In Major League Baseball (MLB), respect isn’t just earned on the field. It’s built in the dugouts and front offices too.

Recently, over 100 MLB players took part in an anonymous poll about which managers and organizations they respect—or don’t. The results offer a glimpse into how players see leadership, culture, and priorities across the league.

From legendary managers to teams with deep traditions, the survey says a lot about where the sport stands. Let’s dig into what the players revealed.

MLB’s Most Respected Managers: Experience and Leadership Top the List

The poll made one thing obvious: players want experienced, confident leaders. Bruce Bochy of the Texas Rangers led the way.

At 70, Bochy’s reputation is almost larger than life. He’s got three World Series titles, decades of wisdom, and a knack for inspiring his clubhouse. Even after coming out of retirement, he’s still the guy players trust.

Other Notable Names in the Managerial Hierarchy

Terry Francona of the Cleveland Guardians followed closely behind. Players appreciate his old-school style and his two World Series wins with Boston.

Between Bochy and Francona, there’s a combined six World Series rings. That kind of track record just can’t be ignored.

Stephen Vogt, surprisingly, landed third. He’s a first-year manager, but players love his relatability and the fun vibe he brings.

As a former catcher, Vogt gets the player perspective. That player-first mindset really stands out.

Craig Counsell (Brewers), Brian Snitker (Braves), and Dave Roberts (Dodgers) also made the list. Each has their own style—whether it’s strategy, emotional smarts, or steady success. Players notice and remember that.

The Least Desired Managers: Struggles and Unfamiliarity Play a Role

Not everyone came out looking great. Bud Black (Rockies) and Oli Marmol (Cardinals) were among the least popular managers.

Players pointed to poor team performance and a lack of real connection with current stars. It’s tough to overcome that reputation.

Other Managers Facing Criticism

Mike Shildt and Ron Washington didn’t fare much better. It wasn’t always about their skills—it was more about tough team situations and not really clicking with today’s players.

In a league that’s always changing, managers need to keep up and stay in sync with their clubhouse. That’s just the reality now.

Organizations That Players Respect: Deep Traditions and Resources Shine

Players also weighed in on MLB organizations themselves. The Dodgers and Yankees sat right at the top.

These teams have the resources, the facilities, and the history. Players notice how they invest in both winning and player welfare.

Additional Franchises Garnering Praise

The Braves, Cubs, Mets, and Guardians earned praise too. Players like that they build strong rosters and focus on player development.

It’s not just about money—it’s the culture and the drive to contend every season. That’s what makes these teams attractive.

The Struggling Organizations: Battles with Poor Reputations

Some franchises just can’t shake their bad reputations. The Athletics, White Sox, Marlins, and Pirates all ranked low.

Players pointed to small payrolls, outdated facilities, and what feels like a lack of real commitment to winning. It’s a tough cycle to break.

The Impact of Organizational Challenges

Players care about an organization’s reputation, especially when deciding where to sign or accept a trade. Poor morale, old facilities, and shaky front offices drive players away.

The poll results make that pretty clear—players want more than just a paycheck. They want to feel like their team is all in, too.

Final Takeaways: What This Means for MLB’s Future

This anonymous poll gives us a rare look into how MLB players really see the league’s leadership. Respect comes from success, tradition, and showing players you care.

Managers like Bochy and Francona, and teams like the Dodgers and Yankees, set a high standard for a winning culture. Meanwhile, teams like the Athletics and Pirates face big challenges if they want to attract and keep top talent.

MLB keeps changing, and honestly, balancing player needs with modern facilities feels more important than ever. Building a competitive team isn’t just about winning—it’s about creating a place where players actually want to be.

 
Here is the source article for this story: MLB players make it clear they don’t want to play for the A’s, but which managers, teams do they like?