White Sox Sign Anthony Kay to Two-Year Deal

The Chicago White Sox are doubling down on a strategy that’s been quietly reshaping pitching markets: they’re searching for undervalued arms overseas and betting on reinvention. Their new two-year, $12 million agreement with left-hander Anthony Kay — plus a 2028 mutual option that could push the deal higher — signals they’re hoping for the next Erick Fedde-style comeback, a pitcher who returns from Asia not just refreshed, but fundamentally different.

White Sox Invest in Anthony Kay’s Reinvention

This deal with Kay aims to balance upside and risk. It’s a familiar move for a club that wants to rebuild its rotation without making long-term, expensive commitments.

The contract is worth $12 million over two years, with a $10 million mutual option for 2028 and a $2 million buyout. There’s also up to $1.5 million in incentives, so Kay could earn more if he becomes a reliable rotation piece.

Contract Structure Reflects Moderate Risk, High Upside

The mutual option gives both sides some flexibility. If Kay pitches well, the Sox can keep him or maybe even trade him for value.

If things don’t work out, they pay the buyout and move on, avoiding those long, risky deals general manager Chris Getz keeps warning about.

From Struggling MLB Arm to NPB Standout

Anthony Kay’s first MLB run didn’t exactly scream breakout payday. But his time in Japan’s Nippon Professional Baseball turned him into one of the more intriguing reclamation arms on the 2025 market.

With the Mets, Blue Jays, and Cubs, Kay posted a 5.59 ERA over five seasons. He struggled with command, walked too many hitters, and couldn’t finish at-bats efficiently.

Dominant Turn in Japan with Yokohama DeNA BayStars

Everything changed in Japan. With the Yokohama DeNA BayStars, Kay threw 291 2/3 innings across two seasons, put up a sharp 2.53 ERA, and struck out 20.9% of hitters.

That’s not just progress — those are the numbers of a pitcher who figured out how to manage lineups, not just survive them. NPB isn’t MLB, but the competition is real, and success there usually means something’s actually improved.

A New Arsenal for a New Opportunity

The biggest reason Chicago sees Kay as a different pitcher now is his reshaped arsenal. They’re not just hoping for luck, they’re betting on new tools.

Kay added velocity to his cutter in Japan and introduced a sinker that’s now central to his approach. That sinker is all about getting more soft contact, letting him go after hitters early instead of always falling behind.

From Power-Only to Pitchability

Earlier in his MLB days, Kay relied on a more basic mix. He didn’t have the refinement to finish hitters or avoid damage when behind.

Now, he’s got a livelier cutter and a sinker built for ground balls, giving him more ways to get through lineups and maybe pitch deeper into games.

For the White Sox, this evolution matters. They’re not paying for the guy with the 5.59 ERA; they’re betting on the one with the 2.53 ERA and a deeper, more modern pitch mix.

Fitting into a Thin White Sox Rotation

Kay joins a rotation that’s wide open. The Sox need stability, innings, and trade value — and Kay could check all those boxes if his NPB form sticks.

Right now, the rotation leans on younger arms like Shane Smith, Sean Burke, and Davis Martin. None of them have locked down a big-league job yet, which gives Kay a real shot to grab a meaningful role early.

Echoes of the Erick Fedde Blueprint

Chicago’s front office isn’t hiding the playbook here. They struck gold with Erick Fedde, who reinvented himself in Korea, came back, and built up enough value to get flipped for prospects.

With payroll around $68 million, the Sox have room to add more veterans around Kay. Still, Getz isn’t eager to hand out long-term deals, so this moderate commitment stands out — and maybe sets the stage for future moves.

Low Cost, High Leverage for the Rebuild

Anthony Kay isn’t really a wild gamble—he’s more like a calculated portfolio play. The club’s risk here is pretty minimal.

With pitching options this thin, that upside looks pretty tempting. If Kay brings his NPB form to the American League, the White Sox get a cost-controlled rotation arm or maybe a midseason trade chip.

If it doesn’t work out, the financial loss is small, and they can move on. In a rebuild, every roster spot needs to pull double duty as both performance and potential trade value.

Honestly, Kay feels like the kind of bet a front office should keep making, especially when the margins are this tight.

 
Here is the source article for this story: White Sox, Anthony Kay Agree To Two-Year Deal