Anthony Volpe Back in Yankees Lineup After Two-Game Bench Stint

The New York Yankees head into Tuesday’s game against the Washington Nationals with a bit of momentum. After a rough stretch against the Boston Red Sox, they bounced back with two wins—thanks in part to a shakeup at shortstop.

Manager Aaron Boone plans to put Anthony Volpe back in the starting lineup. That move’s already sparked debate among fans and analysts. Could this be the moment that reignites Volpe’s promise? Or is it just inviting more defensive headaches as the playoff push ramps up?

Yankees Recover After Red Sox Setback

The Yankees’ series with the Red Sox was brutal. Boone didn’t hide his frustration with how things went.

Anthony Volpe, the young shortstop, became the most obvious casualty of the sweep. After a string of defensive mistakes, Boone swapped him out for Jose Caballero. Caballero’s steadier glove made an instant difference.

Caballero Makes His Case

With Caballero at short, New York notched two convincing wins. They outscored opponents by ten runs across those games.

His defense calmed the infield, and he chipped in with timely hits. The team’s mood noticeably improved, and the errors that had haunted them seemed to vanish—at least for a couple games.

Volpe’s Defensive Struggles Under the Microscope

Volpe’s talent is obvious, but the glove just hasn’t been there this year. He’s second in the league in errors, only behind Cincinnati’s Elly De La Cruz.

Yankee fans have noticed, and the criticism has been relentless. With the AL East so tight, every mistake feels like a disaster. Patience is wearing thin, honestly.

Fan Frustration and Split Opinions

When Boone said Volpe would start Tuesday, social media lit up. Some fans are rooting for him, hoping he’ll snap out of this funk and bring a spark both in the field and at the plate.

Others see disaster coming, accusing Boone of ignoring the obvious and sticking with analytics instead of trusting Caballero’s hot hand.

• Supporters think Volpe’s bat is worth the risk on defense.
• Critics argue Caballero’s recent play makes him the obvious choice.
• Some just shrug and figure Boone’s taking a calculated risk for the bigger picture.

The Role of Analytics in Boone’s Decision

Boone’s always tried to blend analytics with gut instinct. In this case, it seems the numbers on Volpe’s offensive upside tipped the scales.

Sure, advanced stats matter, but plenty of fans wish recent results had more sway—especially when the team’s winning with Caballero.

Short Leash for the Young Shortstop

Boone hasn’t promised Volpe unlimited chances. If the errors keep coming, Caballero is ready to jump back in, even mid-game.

It’s a flexible plan, and Boone clearly knows what’s at stake—wins, morale, all of it.

Looking Ahead in the AL East

The Yankees are still chasing the Toronto Blue Jays. Every game feels huge as the standings tighten.

Starting Volpe could be a bold move that pays off, or it could cost them. With the postseason race getting wild, every inning’s going to matter.

High-Stakes Baseball in the Bronx

For Volpe, this isn’t just a return to the lineup. It’s a test of his resilience.

Boone faces his own challenge, trying to balance development with results. Fans? They’re watching closely, questioning if the manager’s choices will actually pay off.

Tuesday night’s game might tell us something—maybe not everything, but something—about whether this move keeps the Yankees climbing or sends them stumbling like they did in Boston.

One thing’s for sure: everyone’s watching Anthony Volpe tonight against Washington. Yankee Stadium doesn’t leave much room for error, and the critics are never quiet.

Redemption’s on the table if he wants to grab it.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Yankees’ Anthony Volpe returns to lineup after two-game bench stint