Blue Jays Sign Tyler Rogers to Three-Year Deal

The Toronto Blue Jays have rolled the dice on durability and deception. They just landed veteran reliever Tyler Rogers on a three-year, $37 million deal that could stretch to a fourth season.

It’s a bold move for a 35-year-old pitcher with an unconventional delivery. Toronto wants to stabilize the back end of its bullpen and chase contention in the coming seasons, and this signing screams all-in.

Blue Jays Bet Big on Tyler Rogers’ Submarine Arsenal

The agreement with Rogers, a free agent coming off a stellar campaign, is pending a physical. It includes an $11 million vesting option for the 2029 season.

If Rogers hits certain appearance numbers, that option kicks in. His future in Toronto now ties directly to the durability that’s defined his career.

For the Blue Jays, this isn’t just another bullpen move. They’re investing heavily in a specialist with a style and track record that’s anything but ordinary—maybe even a little risky, but intriguing.

A Late Bloomer Who Refused to Break

Rogers’ path to this payday hasn’t been typical. The San Francisco Giants drafted him in the 10th round back in 2013.

He spent six long seasons grinding through the minors before finally debuting in 2019—just shy of his 29th birthday. Since reaching the big leagues, he’s made over 400 appearances and never hit the injured list. That’s almost unheard of for a modern reliever.

Toronto noticed. That kind of durability is a big reason they went three guaranteed years for a pitcher approaching his mid-30s.

The Submarine Edge: Low Stress, High Results

Rogers is known for his rare submarine delivery, releasing the ball from a low arm slot that practically scrapes the mound. That underhand motion puts less strain on his shoulder and elbow than traditional overhand deliveries, which helps explain his clean medical history.

He doesn’t blow hitters away with velocity. Instead, he leans on deception and movement.

Hitters see the ball from a weird angle, with sink and sweep that mess with timing and barrel control. It’s a style built for soft contact and ground balls—perfect for those late innings when one mistake can decide everything.

How Rogers Changes the Blue Jays’ Bullpen Picture

In his final season before free agency, Rogers posted a sparkling 1.98 ERA and led all of Major League Baseball with 81 appearances for the New York Mets. That combination of effectiveness and availability is exactly what the Blue Jays have missed in high-leverage spots.

Toronto plans to use Rogers as a primary setup option. He’ll bridge the gap between the middle innings and the final outs—a role that’s almost as valuable as closing these days.

High-Leverage Triumvirate: Rogers, Varland, and Hoffman

Rogers joins a late-game mix that already includes Louis Varland and Jeff Hoffman. Manager John Schneider now has multiple looks to deploy against different lineup pockets.

Instead of leaning on just one late-inning arm, the Blue Jays can attack teams with a trio of contrasting styles:

This layered approach gives Toronto flexibility. Maybe Rogers neutralizes right-handed clusters, handles seventh- and eighth-inning traffic, or steps in on back-to-back days when others need rest.

A Rare Multi-Year Commitment to a 35-Year-Old Reliever

The three-year term, with a possible fourth, is unusual for a pitcher of Rogers’ age. MLB clubs usually avoid multi-year deals for mid-30s relievers—unless you’re talking about Mariano Rivera anchoring the Yankees’ pen into his 40s.

By locking in Rogers through at least his age-37 season, the Blue Jays are betting that his low-stress mechanics and proven durability will age better than the average power reliever whose value depends on velocity.

Financial Impact: Deep into Luxury Tax Territory

This is not a budget move. Rogers’ contract pushes Toronto’s payroll deeper into luxury tax territory, with projections suggesting an extra tax bill in the $8–9 million range.

For ownership, that’s a clear sign the competitive window is now—and that shoring up the bullpen is worth the financial hit.

Add in the vesting option, and the Blue Jays are basically committing to the idea that Rogers will keep being one of the game’s most reliable workhorses out of the bullpen. Not just a short-term plug, but a real piece of the plan.

What Rogers’ Signing Signals About Toronto’s Ambitions

The Blue Jays just invested heavily in a veteran reliever with a specialized skill set. That move screams win-now mentality, doesn’t it?

This is the kind of aggressive bullpen addition you usually see from contenders who think they’re just a few high-leverage outs away from flipping their October story.

If Rogers keeps being that same tireless, quietly dominant force he’s shown since 2019, the deal starts to look less like a luxury and more like a necessity. Toronto seems determined to finally turn all that regular-season promise into something real in the playoffs.

 
Here is the source article for this story: Blue Jays Sign Tyler Rogers To Three-Year Deal